Batman: Arkham City Review

Minus a little “sequel-envy,” Arkham City is a worthy successor to the best superhero game.

$60.00 MSRP
8.3 score Tested by Experts
  • The Batman Arkham City is better than 62% of the video games we tested.
  • It is better than 63% of the video games we have tested under $100.


With little exception, superhero games were a bit of an industry joke, known mostly for timely cash-ins and half-finished ideas. That all changed in 2009, when Rocksteady Studios released Batman: Arkham Asylum. Rocksteady is of course a prolific developer that's been making games since way back in '04. Yes, they're the ones responsible for the modern classic Urban Chaos: Riot Response, and yes, that's sarcasm you're reading. Nevertheless, the newcomers at Rocksteady Bat-slapped naysayers and delivered one of the best games of the year, licensed or otherwise.

Given the success of Arkham Asylum, Rocksteady was quick to turn around a sequel, delivering Batman: Arkham City in a little over two years, and extending the company's streak of games with subtitled names. The plan for Batman: Arkham City was to take the Asylum formula but expand it to a larger, more open world, and ultimately their goal was achieved successfully.

This review is based on over 25 hours of gameplay, including a complete campaign playthrough, plus five hours of experimentation with New Game + and the "Riddler Challenge Rooms." Downloadable content was installed according to availability at the time of the game's release. All impressions are from the Xbox 360 version.

Comparable Products

Before you buy the Batman Arkham City, take a look at these other video games.


  1. Page
  2. Gameplay
  3. Storytelling
  4. Graphics & Atmosphere
  5. Conclusion

News and Features

Cowa robot hero 1

This robot suitcase will follow you (almost) anywhere

The Internet of Things will come to all the things, suitcases included.

P1250211 small

CES Asia is small, but growing exponentially

CES's expansion into China hits the ground running.

Chromecast audio hero

This weekend's best audio deals

We gathered the best deals on audio tech you'll find this weekend.

Umbrella hero 1

Stuff We Love: Davek Umbrellas

How a $100 umbrella taught me to "buy it once, buy it right."

Kindle paperwhite mothers day hero

The best Mother's Day gadget deals

We gathered the best deals on gadgets you can find for mom.

Lg chromebase

This week's best computer deals

We rounded up the internet's best deals on computers.

Walmart hero1

The Best Deals From Walmart's Big Spring Sale

We track down the best deals from Walmart's spring Rollback sale.

Home depot hero

The Best Deals From Home Depot's Spring Black Friday Sale

We help you sort through Home Depot's annual Spring Black Friday sale.

Super bowl landing page hero 2's Ultimate Guide to the Big Game

Your one-stop shop for football's biggest weekend.