Skip to main content
DEAL WATCH: 5-star sofa to tie the room together $898.00

Sink into this comfy, top-rated sofa we've found at Walmart. Pick it up yourself, or next-day shipping is available in some areas. | Read Review

BUY NOW
Home & Garden

10 pumpkin spice products that are more fail than Fall

Are you as tired of pumpkin spice as we are?

10 pumpkin spice products that are more fail than Fall Credit: Getty Images

Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed's editors. Purchases made through the links below may earn us and our publishing partners a commission.

Ah, fall! Crisp temperatures, colorful leaves, and pumpkins everywhere.

Well, not everywhere. Until 2015, Starbucks didn’t put any actual pumpkin in its pumpkin spice latte. But that didn’t stop the PSL (as my Pinterest friends call it) from gaining celebrity status and spawning such an intense craze. I mean, the darn drink has its own Twitter account—it is even verified!

Related content

  • pumpkins

    feature

    Why everyone needs to stop freaking out about pumpkin spice
  • Three digital picture frames displaying family photos sit on a wooden table.

    best-right-now

    The Best Digital Picture Frames of 2024

The trend may be peaking, however, as Americans are beginning to realize that most pumpkin spice creations are ridiculous, and sometimes just ghastly. Yet there are still so many useless pumpkin spice items on the market—many of which we had the misfortune of trying. In the spirit of 2017, here are 10 pumpkin spice items we think you should skip.

1. Bigelow Pumpkin Spice Tea

Pumpkin Spice Tea
Credit: Bigelow

With a flavor that reminded us more of black licorice than cinnamon or pumpkin, this tea is one to avoid.

2. Nest Pumpkin Chai Candle

Pumpkin Chai Scented Candle
Credit: Candlefrenzy

This high-end candle claims that it’s made with “wild pumpkin”. So, I looked it up—wild pumpkin is a squash known for its fetid odor, and it's poisonous! Go ahead, google it.

3. The Honest Kitchen Pumpkin Spice Latte for pets

Pets can have lattes, too
Credit: The Honest Kitchen

Your heart is in the right place, but your canine and feline will get along fine without this treat.

4. Frosted Pumpkin Pie Pop Tarts

Pumpkin Spice Pop Tarts
Credit: Reviewed.com / Jonathan Chan

Pumpkin is indeed listed in the ingredients, but we could taste no discernible pumpkin flavor. We are all for the autumn-colored sprinkles, though.

5. Desert Essence Pumpkin Spice Hand Repair Cream

Pumpkin spice hand cream
Credit: Walmart

I'm sure it's great, but I'm worried that a squirrel might bite your hand.

6. Pinnacle Pumpkin Pie Vodka

Pumpkin pie vodka
Credit: Intoxicology

No, seriously, don't drink this. It’s far too sweet, and sweet alcohol is always dangerous.

7. Claire’s Pumpkin Spice Latte Phone Case

Phone case
Credit: Claire's

Please resist the urge to be this extra.

8. CVS Pumpkin Spice Cough Drops

Pumpkin Spice Cough Drops
Credit: CVS

Pumpkin and menthol, really? The thought alone of placing one of these in my mouth is heinous.

9. White Pumpkin Pie M&Ms

M&Ms pumpkin pie candies
Credit: Amazon

The orange M&M on the bag looks pretty concerned. Assume he has reason to be. Pass!

10. Earth’s Best Organic Pumpkin & Spinach Baby Food Puree

Pumpkin and spinach baby food
Credit: Walmart

Okay, there’s no spice in this. But if your baby will eat pumpkin and spinach puree, your parenting skills are awesome. If I had tried to feed that to my kiddo, I would have ended up wearing it. Instead, see if your little one will eat Pumpkin Spice Cheerios. They're delicious.

Up next