Certain serial numbers of this model may be affected by this issue. As such, we have chosen to rescind our Editors’ Choice award for this product until we have more information on Samsung’s plans to remedy the situation.

Let's be clear about one thing: The Samsung WA52J8700AP (MSRP $1,199 in platinum or $1,099 in white) is the most innovative washer we've seen in years.

Its unique Activewash system puts a sink on top of the washing machine, complete with a faucet and ribbed basin for soaking or pretreating the stains that you or your kids left behind. When you're done hand washing, just open the lid and your laundry will fall into the drum. It's a remarkably simple solution for users who don't have a sink in the laundry room, and the white WA52J8700AW can be found online for just $849.

So why, then, doesn't it get a perfect 10 score? Well, a lot of the features that make the WA52J8700AP easier to use and popular with some consumers also have minor drawbacks. For instance, a top-loading washer will always struggle with stain removal and water efficiency compared to a front-loading counterpart. The Activewash basin can sometimes make it harder to load laundry. And while the SuperSpeed setting is truly superb—shaving ten minutes off a wash—it isn't part of the washer's default Normal cycle, which is what the vast majority of American users choose.

In general, the WA52J8700AP is an above-average performer, and one of the better top-load machines we've tested—but it is clearly designed for a specific consumer. If you prefer a hands-on approach to doing laundry, you'll love the Samsung Activewash. We certainly do. But if you're the sort who ignores care tags, doesn't sort laundry, and wants the washer to do all the work, look elsewhere.

Cleaning performance is determined by stain removal, and to measure this we use standardized, mechanically coated stain strips. These cloth swatches are covered in common household substances like cocoa, sweat, blood, oil, and red wine. We place these strips into eight-pound test loads and wash them on key cycles. When each cycle is finished, we analyze the strips with a photospectrometer to determine how close to white each stain is. A computer then precisely determines how much of each stain has been lifted.

The Samsung WA52J8700AP did an above-average job removing stains. For instance, the Heavy Duty cycle got clothes closer to white than most machines, and performed the best of all the cycles on this Samsung. It was about 2% more effective than the Whites cycle–the next most effective cycle. The Brilliant Whites cycle was 7% more effective than the Normal cycle. The Quick Wash was the weakest, lagging 23% behind the Heavy Duty cycle. We'd recommend using SuperSpeed instead and waiting a little longer for a wash that's closer to Normal.

Against individual stains, across the board the WA56J8700AP did particularly well against cocoa and red wine, but struggled to lift sweat stains.

Yep, it has a sink on top

The most interesting part of the WA52J8700AP is its Activewash system (Samsung styles it "activewash"). It puts a 1-cu.-ft. sink underneath the washer's lid. Open it, and you'll find a plastic basin with a ribbed interior. These ribs act like the washboards of old—except, instead of going down to the river to get water, you can simply press a button at the front of the machine to activate a small spout.

Fill the basin to presoak your laundry, or wet it and scrub it against the side of the tub to remove fresh stains. When you're done, simply tilt the whole washbasin back and—thanks to a trick latch that connects the basin and lid—all the pretreated laundry and dirty water fall into the washing machine drum, ready for a cycle. Pretreating your laundry is almost always the way to go when it comes to tough stains, and Activewash makes it easier than any washing machine ever has.

We loved the idea of Activewash when we first tried it out at CES, but didn't know how actual users would react. So we brought in our editor's mother—a lifelong laundry pretreater—to try it out. (Apparently, interest in appliances is a hereditary trait.) She loved it, too—noting that she wouldn't have to go upstairs to soak clothes in the kitchen sink, and that the spout could also be used to fill a spray bottle for ironing.

But if you aren't a power washing machine user, or if you already have a utility sink and counter in your laundry room, the Activewash basin could get in the way. We found that the added weight of the basin was enough to make the lid slam shut, for instance. After just a week's worth of use, the lettering on the detergent drawer started to peel off. Sometimes the water jet would splash outside the basin, and the basin occasionally wouldn't latch tightly to the lid—making it more difficult to tilt dirty laundry into the machine.

Other than Activewash, the WA52J8700AP's design language is familiar. Awhile back, Samsung decided on a standard aesthetic for its top loaders, which is why the WA56DRHSDU, the WA56H9000AP, and the WA50F9A8DSP all share the same general look. We think that's a good thing: The dial is simple and easy to read, and all the feature buttons are large to avoid confusion.

Meanwhile, down in the drum...

Cool features don't give the WA52J8700AP a pass in our tests, in which we determine how good it is at removing stains, spinning out excess water, and not destroying clothing in the process.

For our stain removal test, we washed away everything from cocoa to red wine. The Heavy Duty cycle aced all of our stain tests, and did particularly well against cocoa and dirt stains. But our water meters told us why Heavy Duty was so effective: it used 34 gallons of water, 16 gallons of which were hot. Such water usage makes the Heavy Duty cycle the most expensive to run.

The Normal cycle used half as much water, and was only 8% less effective than Heavy Duty. We'd recommend it for most cycles. SuperSpeed is designed to take only 36 minutes, but—unlike LG's similar TurboWash—the faster wash cycle isn't a default setting. We'd still select it to get clothes done in a hurry.

On other metrics, the WA52J8700AP was at or below average: It wasn't particularly gentle on clothes, and it didn't excel at spinning out excess water. That means extra costs down the line—whether it's buying new clothes or running your dryer for longer.

We use average national costs and typical user behavior to determine how much a washing machine will cost to operate in total. In the case of the WA52J8700AP, water and energy should run $66 a year. Even for thirsty top loaders, that's a few dollars more than average—mostly due to thirsty optional cycles. It's also about double what an efficient front loader would use. Over the washer's lifespan, that's about $660, plus detergent and any out-of-warranty repairs. These numbers don't make or break this Samsung, but it's something to consider if you're investing for the long haul.

For in-depth performance information, please visit the Science Page.
Efficiency is about water usage and water retention. Based on average national utility costs and use patterns, we estimate this Samsung's annual running cost to be around $66. That's pretty high, even for a top loader, and it's mostly due to a Heavy Duty cycle that repeatedly used lots of water.

The second aspect of efficiency is water retention. The amount of water your laundry retains is the amount of water your dryer will eventually have to spin out, and dryers are typically the home's greediest energy hogs. In this regard, Samsung didn't do so well either. On average, laundry retained 71% of its weight in water. Anything over 50% starts to get points docked.
Like many appliance manufacturers, Samsung offers different warranty coverage depending on what goes wrong with a washer. The WA52J8700AP has a one-year parts and labor warranty, plus a two-year warranty on its control board, a three-year warranty for its stainless drum, and a ten-year warranty on its washing motor.

For the right buyer, it's the perfect washing machine

For many, doing laundry is a lot more involved than just throwing it in the washer. Those folks might have kids or pets, or they might just love fashion. They want the cleanest clothes possible, and they know they need to pretreat. With Activewash, the Samsung WA52J8700AP lets you take care of your clothes more conveniently.

Is the Activewash feature worth it? If you find yourself running between the kitchen sink and the laundry room when you need to pretreat, it definitely is. This 1-cu.-ft. basin effectively puts a utility sink on top of your washer, saving time and hassle, and closing the gap between hand washing and machine washing. In a Platinum finish, the WA52J8700AP usually sells for around $1,000—but the white Samsung WA52J8700AW can be found for as low as $849—a great deal.

If you prefer a hands-off approach—or if you already have a sink—other washers are more efficient and do a better job removing stains. We love the Activewash, but it's up to you whether it fits in your laundry day routine.

Editor's Note

THIS ARTICLE WAS UPDATED ON Oct. 4, 2016 TO REFLECT NEW INFORMATION ABOUT SAMSUNG WASHING MACHINES.

Meet the testers

Jonathan Chan

Jonathan Chan

Lab Manager

@ReviewedHome

Jonathan Chan currently serves as the Senior Lab Technician at Reviewed. If you clean with it, it's likely that Jon oversees its testing. Since joining the Reviewed in 2012, Jon has helped launch the company's efforts in reviewing laptops, vacuums, and outdoor gear. He thinks he's a pretty big deal. In the pursuit of data, he's plunged his hands into freezing cold water, consented to be literally dragged through the mud, and watched paint dry. Jon demands you have a nice day.

See all of Jonathan Chan's reviews

Checking our work.

We use standardized and scientific testing methods to scrutinize every product and provide you with objectively accurate results. If you’ve found different results in your own research, email us and we’ll compare notes. If it looks substantial, we’ll gladly re-test a product to try and reproduce these results. After all, peer reviews are a critical part of any scientific process.

Shoot us an email

Up next