We shopped Amazon to recreate NYFW trends—here's how it went

Anyone who's into fashion waits with bated breath for the major players to reveal the season's trends. Is it something you've already been wearing? Something you can pull from your closet? Or, in some cases, do you have to grab new pieces to integrate into your wardrobe?

This year's New York Fashion Week (NYFW) was full of unique pieces and stunning craftsmanship, but a few key trends stood out. I grabbed five pieces from Amazon to see if I could recreate the season's hottest trends.

Fall florals: Rooscier Women's Cloak Sleeve Midi Dress

Fall florals were a major part of NYFW, and this dress is the perfect match. The pleats and short-sleeve cape scream fall, while autumn-toned florals perfect the look.

What I liked

Opening an online order can be a jump scare if what arrives is completely different from what the photo depicted online. Fortunately, the color, pattern, and cut of this dress were identical to the photo. The pleating adds a bit of visual interest without distracting from the floral pattern. The sleeves are flowy and slightly sheer, which adds a touch of elegance, while the bodice is double lined and not see-through, even in direct sunlight.

What I didn't like

I noticed a deodorant stain on the dress as soon as I pulled it out of the package, which was disappointing, but it was a quick fix with a washcloth and a bit of water. My shoulders and arms are on the larger side thanks to years spent in the gym, but the cut made some movements slightly awkward, with the fabric pulling tight across the shoulders.

Bold proportions: Xponni Bell Sleeve Top

Bold proportions were everywhere this year, from blouses with shoulder pads to asymmetrical bubble-hem skirts. This piece is more wearable for day-to-day activities, with fun balloon sleeves and a lightweight, sheer fabric.

What I liked

This shirt is unique, with ruching details that stand out even in a neutral color like white. Though it was a one-size-fits-all top, it had ample stretch and was lightweight.

What I didn't like

I was expecting this shirt to be somewhat sheer because of the flowy polyester material, especially since I ordered it in the lightest color. But I didn't expect the combination of white and thin, sheer fabric to make it feel more like a paper towel than a fun, dimensional piece. The elastic that gave the sleeves their distinct balloon shape was also visible because of how sheer the fabric was, giving the shoulders and arms a hint of gray against the white. Even a nude bra underneath was still clearly visible.

Art deco–inspired: MakeMeChic Sequin Fringe Midi Skirt

Art deco was another recurring runway spot. This skirt is the perfect match of flirty and fun, with sparkling sequins and a sultry mesh material.

What I liked

The diamond patterns, sequins, and fringe details are beautiful. Trying to find an art deco piece that doesn't feel like a Halloween costume can be difficult, but the intricate detailing and elevated slit on this one set it apart. Even though the skirt itself is sheer, there are tons of ways to style it, from keeping it modest with a long black tee or sweater on top to playing up the drama with a white tee and a pair of black briefs underneath.

What I didn't like

The material of the skirt has a weird net-like texture that's slightly rigid and plasticky, which wasn't what I was expecting. The hem was left raw and was already fraying a bit before I had even tried it on. There was some gaping in the waist even though I ordered a size small, stated to have a 26-inch waist, which is my exact measurement.

Elevated officewear: Grace Karin Tweed Pencil Dress

What I liked

This dress was flattering, thanks to the unique neckline, structure in the bust, and slightly stretchy fabric. The back zipper spans nearly three-quarters of the length, which, along with the stretch of the fabric, made it easy to zip up on my own. The neckline was high enough that there was no chance of spilling or inappropriate cleavage when worn in a work setting.

What I didn't like

Certain arm movements made the cap sleeves tighten awkwardly around my shoulders, where the fabric is much more rigid than in the bodice. I wish there were more structure and less stretch in the skirt portion of the dress. The fabric also looked a bit sheer initially, but I had no problems, even when wearing dark undergarments.

Elevated basics: siliteelon Cinched Waist Fitted Blouse

What I liked

When I think of a white button-up, I can't help but think of a suffocating, starched, and pressed piece. This one was nothing like that; the fabric was soft and pliable, offering a full range of motion without pulling tight in the shoulders or gaping in the chest. The elastic across the back cinches in the waist without feeling restrictive, giving extra breathing room after a meal or when needing full range of motion.

What I didn't like

The cotton blend was soft and had a slight stretch, but it was wrinkly out of the package and even after washing.

Should you shop New York Fashion Week trends on Amazon?

Yes, if you're willing to dig for high-quality pieces

Some trends, like workwear or fall florals, are much easier to find on Amazon than art deco or sheer pieces. There are options out there, but it might take a bit of looking. Overall, I'm excited about what I grabbed and think these pieces will be versatile enough to mix and match across trends.