• Wusthof Gourmet Offset Slotted Spatula

  • Cutco Turn n’ Serve

  • Di Oro Seamless Spatula

  • Ateco 1385 4.5” Offset Spatula

  • KitchenAid Slotted Turner

  • How We Tested

  • A Few Things to Know about Spatulas

  • Other Spatulas We Tested

  • More Articles You Might Enjoy

Our Favorite Spatulas of 2019

  1. Best Overall

    Wüsthof Gourmet Slotted Spatula, 6-1/2-Inch

    Skip to the full review below
Best Spatulas: Best Overall
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

This sleek fish turner is the best spatula we tested.

Best Overall
Wusthof Gourmet Offset Slotted Spatula

A slotted spatula, or fish spatula, might seem like an odd choice if you don’t spend much time making fish—but they also make great overall spatulas. They’re best for delicate tasks like cooking eggs and tofu and fish, but can also be great for pancakes and cookies and other tasks you’d typically do with a flat spatula. And of the offset slotted spatulas we tested, the Wusthof reigned supreme.

Like its fellows, this delicate turner features a slight curve to the head and an angled end. Unlike a few of them, the Wusthof also has an extra angle right at the tip to more easily slide under delicate tofu skin and lightly set eggs. This made it especially wonderful for handling over-easy eggs and other delicate foods. The best part? It also worked great on burgers, pancakes, and cookies.

To top it off, the handle is sleek but with enough heft to really grab onto and maneuver. And thanks to its wood-free construction, it can easily be cleaned by tossing it into a dishwasher.

Best Spatulas: Flat
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

Our favorite flat spatula from Cutco is surprisingly versatile.

Best Flat Spatula
Cutco Turn n’ Serve

A flat cooking spatula is a kitchen staple—ideal for removing cookies from a baking tray, flipping pancakes and eggs, and any other cooking task that requires slipping under food to move it around. And the Cutco Turn n’ Serve flat cooking spatula takes the cake. (No seriously, we used it to move a cake and it worked great.) It’s more expensive than I would typically recommend for a spatula, but this is a “you get what you pay for” situation. It’s pricey, but comes with a lifetime guarantee and will never send you back to your utensil drawer looking for a better tool.

This spatula performed incredibly well on all of our tests. The flat head is thin enough to easily slide under delicate eggs and tofu, but sturdy enough to flip burgers and lift a cake from a cake turner onto a serving plate. It’s a good size as well. It hits the sweet spot between being narrow enough to fit into your brownie pan and lift out a piece, and wide enough to be useful for flipping pancakes and removing cookies from your baking tray.

The only downside I found with this spatula is that it’s metal. And while this allows it to be as thin as a delicate fish spatula, it cannot be used on a nonstick pan. So if you only use nonstick cookware, you will have to opt for a silicone tool.

Best Spatulas: Baking
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

Our best baking spatula is great for mixing, folding, and spreading.

Best Baking Spatula
Di Oro Seamless Spatula

Everyone needs a silicone baking spatula, and the Di Oro Large Silicone Spatula is an excellent choice for folding flour into your batter and then scraping down the sides of your bowl. It’s a single, slick piece of silicone, so you don’t need to worry about the head snapping off. The handle is sturdy and solid, while the head is just flexible enough to scrape down tricky-to-reach areas of your bowl.

The one-side-curved, one-side-straight head of this spatula makes it excellent for reaching into different types of corners (for instance, when scraping dough from a round bowl or when smoothing brownie batter into a square tin). As well, the medium/large spatula head means you can get the job done quickly and easily. Overall, this spatula worked wonderfully through all our tests, and I’m now considering buying yet another baking spatula for my kitchen.

Best Spatulas: Icing
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

A good frosting spatula needs to be thin enough for detail work.

Best Frosting Spatula
Ateco 1385 4.5” Offset Spatula

The most niche of the spatula categories is the offset baking spatula, which works best for frosting cakes and cupcakes, and cutting/removing brownies from a tray. That said, they also work well for flipping pancakes and sliding cookies off a tray, so don’t count them out!

The small Ateco offset baking spatula topped our tests in this category. Delicate and perfectly shaped, it’s ideal for spreading frosting—and for making interesting textures and patterns if you’re into decorating. The narrow blade is perfect for getting into corners when spreading batter in a pan, and the spatula itself really feels like an extension of your fingers.

The only downside is that the handle is made of wood, so you do need to wash it by hand. (Which, to be honest, takes all of about 60 seconds.)

Best Spatulas: Nonstick
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

If you need a nonstick spatula, this KitchenAid will do the trick.

Best Nonstick Spatula
KitchenAid Slotted Turner

If you have nonstick pans, you’re going to need a nonstick-safe spatula. Since every kitchen needs a flat cooking spatula, the KitchenAid Slotted Gourmet Short Turner is what I would recommend for your non-metal spatula choice. It’s an inexpensive, but still strong, alternative to the Cutco Turn n’ Serve.

This slotted short turner is a bit of a beast, but in a good way. Its long handle and sizable head make it perfect for flipping burgers or frying tofu, and its rigid construction lends itself to moving a heavy cake (or absolutely massive burger). The angled plastic edge also helps it slip under eggs and pancakes. So while this monster cannot handle the delicate work the Cutco or Wustoff can manage, it’s an excellent runner up spatula.

How We Tested

Best Spatulas: All
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

We tested 16 spatulas for our roundup.

The Tester

Hi, I’m Bethany. I’m an avid home cook and frequent home baker. I make a lot of eggs, bake a lot of cookies, and use at least one type of spatula most days.

I also somehow own 14 spatulas already. Most of them were gifts, or ended up in my utensil drawer after roommates abandoned them over the years. I do have favorites though—spatulas that just seem to work better and that I gravitate toward using.

So for this article, I wanted to really dive into the world of spatulas and figure out, once and for all, which ones were the best. Frankly, I do not want to take 14 spatulas with me next time I move.

The Tests

Best Spatulas: Cookies
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

We frosted cakes, scooped cookies, and grilled burgers with our spatulas.

To put our spatulas through their paces, we split them out into four different categories: Flat cooking spatula, baking spatula, slotted spatula, and offset baking spatula. They each serve a different function, with some overlap of course, so we devised a specific set of tests for each and mostly compared them to other spatulas of the same type.

For our flat cooking spatulas, we tested flipping both normal sized and silver dollar pancakes, making and removing over easy eggs from a stainless steel pan, removing cookies from a baking tray, flipping and removing burgers from a pan, and lifting and moving a cake from a cake decorating stand to a serving tray.

For the baking spatulas, we mostly tested their ability to fold flour into batter, to scrape down the sides of bowls that were used to mix brownies and cake, to spread thick brownie batter in a tray, and to melt butter and chocolate together on the stove. Throughout these tests, we were looking to see which could easily maneuver around the inside of the bowl.

With the slotted spatulas, we focused on delicate and precision work. This meant testing over-easy eggs and fried tofu along with the standard tests of cookies, pancakes, and burgers. And then for the offset baking spatulas, we started our tests with baking-specific tasks like spreading frosting before doubling up on the pancake and cookie tests once again. If each of these spatulas couldn’t at least approximate good results with cookies and pancakes, we thought we might rethink the need to keep one in our kitchen.

For each of these spatula categories, we took careful notes on whether the spatulas simply pushed things around the pan, or was actually able to scoot underneath and delicately remove the food. We also paid close attention to how comfortable each was to use, whether they were either too rigid or too flexible for the job, and how easy they were to clean.

A Few Things to Know about Spatulas

Best Spatulas: All
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser

There are at least four types of spatulas to consider when shopping.

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again—it’s worth owning a few different spatulas. While there is some overlap in their usage—both a fish turner and a flat spatula are great for flipping eggs and pancakes—each type of spatula serves essentially a different function. There’s nothing better for scraping down a bowl of batter than a baking spatula, and an offset baking tool can really up your frosting game. If you like to bake in particular, having a few different utensils of this sort on hand can be a godsend.

However, if you only want one or two cluttering up your drawers, I would pick a flat spatula and a baking spatula. That way you have something to flip pancakes and scoop cookies with, but also something to scrape down the side of your bowl or pot with.

A few things to look out for when you’re considering spatulas: Depending on what you plan to use them for, make sure your spatula matches your pans. It goes without saying that you should never use a metal spatula on a nonstick pan. As well, if you’re planning on using your baking spatula on the stove to mix hot ingredients, be sure that it really is heat safe (i.e. made of silicone, not plastic).


Other Spatulas We Tested

GIR Ultimate Spatula

This sturdy silicone spatula was a close runner-up to our baking winner, and for good reason. It’s very similar in size, shape, and material to our top pick. The biggest differences are a slightly narrower and more flexible head, and a handle that is ever-so-slightly shorter. The shape of the head is also slightly different, and we found didn’t scrape bowls of batter quite as well. That said, if you find yourself with this GIR spatula in your drawer, you’re in good hands.

Wilton 9 Inch Angled Spatula

Similar to the Ateco, the Wilton offset baking spatula is overall a bit bigger than its winning counterpart. This wider, longer blade and larger handle make it less ideal for precision icing work. It performed well on all of our tests, but couldn’t beat out the more delicate version that took our top spot. The upside is that, because it’s entirely plastic and metal, you can throw it right in the dishwasher when you’re done.

Tovolo Flex-Core Stainless Steel Handled Spatula

The Tovolo steel-handled spatula is a heavy duty hunk of a tool. It has some heft to it, which I found useful for stirring thick brownie batter full of chocolate chips. The edges of the head don’t bend well, though, making it less useful for sneaking into nooks and crannies. As well, the metal base and the silicone head detach from each other—meaning you do run the risk of eventually needing to clean it in two different pieces. Fortunately, it is dishwasher-safe.

GDYorkitchen Fish Spatula

Rather nondescript, this fish spatula is larger and less comfortable than our winner from Wusthof. It was able to slide under eggs and tofu fairly well, but lost points when it came to comfort because of the way the metal bends around the back. The handle itself is comfortable, but when I needed to scoot my hand closer to the head of the spatula to maneuver under some food, I tended to run into problems.

KSENDALO Kitchen Nonstick Fish Spatula

Typically, fish spatulas are made of metal so they can be thin and delicate enough to slide between a fish and its scales. However, this makes them impossible to use with nonstick cookware. So, I decided to test the KSENDALO Kitchen nonstick fish spatula and see how it compared. It did well enough, working just fine for cookies and burgers and pancakes. However, you could tell that it lacked the same edge as the other metal spatulas when it came time to slide under eggs and tofu. It’s a great option for a nonstick pan, but it just can’t beat the delicate edge of its metal counterparts.

Victorinox 3" by 6" Chef's Slotted Fish Turner, Walnut Handle

The Victorinox slotted fish turner is a wonderful spatula—very similar to the winning Wusthof. The biggest physical difference is the handle. Not only can it not be put in the dishwasher because it’s made of wood, but it’s a bit scratchy to hold. It also didn’t perform quite as well on our tests. These drawbacks, plus its ever-so-slightly shorter handle, bumped it down our list.

Rubbermaid Commercial 9.5 In. High Heat Scraper

If you’re using a massive bowl, this Rubbermaid spatula works like a dream. However, it’s not compatible with smaller bowls. This spatula is huge, more than an inch longer and almost a half inch wider than the next longest baking spatula we tested. This made it tough to use for some of our tests, and it became a bit unwieldy. We also found the hard, ridged plastic handle a tad uncomfortable at times, knocking this further down the list.

GIR Mini Flip

Much like a few of the baking spatulas we tested, this tiny turner is entirely silicone. This makes it comfortable to hold and easy to clean. However, it is tiny. The head of this spatula, while perfect for silver dollar pancakes and fine for small cookies, struggled with the large burgers and the egg whites that had drifted away from the yolk. The angled edge of the head worked well for slipping under foods, though it still occasionally struggled and simply pushed a pancake or egg around the pan. (GIR does sell a larger version of this spatula, though we haven’t tested it yet ourselves. It may work better for some tasks, though it might also suffer from the same issues the other flat spatulas did in terms of being too flexible.)

Castle Cookware Silicone Spatula

Overall, the Castle Cookware flexible silicone turner is a good size and a solid spatula It didn’t struggle too hard with any of our tests, with the exception of moving the cake (which is was simply too flexible to manage). That said, it didn’t excel either. It’s comfortable, and I wouldn’t be unhappy to find it in my drawer, but I would also want to be sure to have a few other spatulas on hand.

Ateco 1387 7.75” Offset Spatula

While its smaller sibling ran off with the prize, the larger Ateco spatula just couldn’t hold up. The sides of the wooden handle feel rather rough, and the blade itself is enormous. So while this worked well enough for frosting a large cake, it struggled with anything requiring precision or a delicate hand.

OXO Good Grips Large Silicone Flexible Turner

Although the handle of the OXO Good Grips turner is the same length as the Castle Cooker spatula, the head on this one is enormous. More than an inch longer and an inch wider than the next largest flat spatula, the OXO literally dwarfs the competition. Unfortunately, this made the spatula difficult to use. It crowded the pan full of pancakes, and was too floppy to help with the cake. Overall, this behemoth just couldn’t hold up to its counterparts.

Meet the testers

Bethany Kwoka

Bethany Kwoka

Contributor

Bethany is a freelance contributor for Reviewed. An avid home baker and aspiring home cook, she reviews and writes mostly about kitchen gadgets (with the occasional fitness review thrown in). Her specialty might be fancy desserts, but she's never met a batch-cooked dinner recipe she didn't like.

Outside of her work for Reviewed, Bethany is a content creator working on clean energy and climate change at a regional non-profit and runs a tabletop game at her local comic book shop.

See all of Bethany Kwoka's reviews

Checking our work.

We use standardized and scientific testing methods to scrutinize every product and provide you with objectively accurate results. If you’ve found different results in your own research, email us and we’ll compare notes. If it looks substantial, we’ll gladly re-test a product to try and reproduce these results. After all, peer reviews are a critical part of any scientific process.

Shoot us an email