It shouldn’t surprise you that a good taco requires a great tortilla. After all, it has so few ingredients you have to make each one count! Since there are dozens of options at the grocery store, you might wonder why it’s worth the bother to make tortillas from scratch at home. I’ll let you in on a little secret: If you’re equipped with the right tools, making corn tortillas is almost easier than driving to the store to buy them. All you need is a specialty flour called masa harina and a decent tortilla press—like our best tested, the Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press(available at Amazon for $19.78).
Making homemade tortillas is an instant way to up your taco game, but you’ll have to decide on a tortilla press before you can get there. There are more than a few options, from lightweight aluminum and heavy-duty cast-iron to beautifully hand-crafted wood presses. Does the press material make a difference in the end result of the tortilla? After testing six top-rated tortilla presses, we can confirm that opting for a good quality press absolutely makes a difference.
Here are the best tortilla presses we tested ranked, in order.
Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press
Central Coast Woodworks 8-Inch Hardwood Tortilla Press (Red Oak & Walnut)
La Mexicana Mesquite Tortilla Press
HIC 6-Inch Tortilla Press
Imusa 8-Inch Aluminum Tortilla Press
Norpro 6-Inch tortilla maker
Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission.
Victoria 8" Cast Iron Tortilla Press
How We Tested Tortilla Presses(and How to Make Corn Tortillas)
The Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press is heavy—it weighs more than 8 pounds—but that heft comes in handy when pressing tortillas. This tortilla press not only stayed put on the counter as we used it, but the weight of the pressing surfaces barely required any effort to transform a round dough ball into a thin, even tortilla. The tortillas were so perfectly flat and consistent that I would happily serve them in a restaurant to paying customers. We also liked that the pressing plates were large enough to prevent the dough from spilling out of the sides if you didn't happen to center the dough perfectly in the middle.
While cast iron isn’t the easiest material to clean, pressing the tortilla in between two pieces of plastic wrap eliminated the need for any messy cleanup. Simply wipe the press clean with a damp towel and rub it dry to prevent rusting. And unlike some of the other heavy presses, the Victoria was low-profile enough to store in a cabinet or drawer without any fuss. Add in the fact that it was so effortless to use and that it pressed tortillas faster than the other models—only 10 seconds per tortilla—and it was a no-brainer to name the Victoria our Best Tortilla Press.
How We Tested Tortilla Presses(and How to Make Corn Tortillas)
Hi, I’m Lindsay Mattison, a trained professional chef and a life-long taco fan. I could eat tacos for breakfast, lunch, and dinner (and, I have on more than one occasions). After a visit to San Antonio, Texas, I became obsessed with recreating the corn tortillas I ate there. It turns out it's super easy to do, and I'd love to help you learn how!
While you can use a tortilla press for rolling out homemade dumpling skins and making empanadas, our tests focused around the one thing the press is designed to do: making corn tortillas. We wanted to know if the material made a difference in the pressing process, both in the effort required to flatten the dough and the final quality of the tortilla itself.
We started by making a standard corn tortilla dough. After mixing 2 cups of masa harina with 1/2 teaspoon salt and 1-1/2 cups warm water, we divided and rolled each portion into 1-ounce balls (which, in case you’re wondering, makes about 19 tortillas). Since tortilla presses aren’t designed to be non-stick, we lined each press with a plastic bag cut in half. Then, we flattened five tortillas in each press before cooking them on a preheated cast iron skillet, flipping them every 30 seconds for two minutes.
With each press, we noted the amount of force required to flatten the dough ball, and whether it created a 6-inch tortilla after the first pressing. We also measured the thickness of each tortilla and assessed whether it was even all the way around. The press lost points if the tortilla was thinner on one side or if the dough spilled out of the side of the press as we used it. Then, we tasted the tortillas to see if we could detect any thick, uncooked pockets or if the edges crisped up because they were pressed too thin. While all of the presses successfully flattened the dough into discs, some of them certainly did a better job than others.
It’s important to note that tortilla presses are for corn tortillas only. Flour tortillas are best rolled with a rolling pin, as the gluten network starts to shrink up as soon as it leaves the press.
A tortilla press is simply two flat surfaces joined together by a handle. When the press is closed, the handle exerts pressure onto the plates, transforming a round dough ball into a flat disc. These presses can be made from anything, but traditional Mexican presses are made with wood. The wooden models are rarely round, and their bulk can make them awkward and cumbersome to use. Cast iron is a great alternative, with the same heft of wood but a significantly smaller profile. You’ll also find aluminum and plastic presses, which are lightweight but require more force to use.
There are also electric models designed to cook and press the tortillas in one fell swoop. We’ve found that these gadgets rarely create restaurant-quality tortillas as they’re also designed to make everything from flatbreads to pancakes. So, we focused on the manual models and cooked each tortilla on a pre-heated cast-iron skillet.
Other Tortilla Presses We Tested
Central Coast Woodworks 8" Hardwood Tortilla Press (Red Oak & Walnut)
There’s no denying that the Central Coast Woodworks 8" Hardwood Tortilla Press would make a gorgeous addition to your kitchen. Made from red oak and walnut, this sturdy press weighed in at 6 pounds and was less intimidating than the other wooden tortilla presses we tested. Its heavy plates squeezed the masa balls with ease, creating perfectly uniform, thin tortillas on the first pressing. We also appreciated that the design kept the handle at an angle as you loaded the next dough ball, preventing it from crashing down and slowing down the process.
While it doesn’t come cheap, it’s also handmade in California and would definitely become a talking piece in your kitchen. If a traditional wooden tortilla press is what you’re after, this is the one to get.
Like the other wooden press, the La Mexicana Mesquite Tortilla Press had no problem flattening our dough balls on the first try. The press was the heaviest model clocking in at an impressive 10 pounds, and it also created some of the thinnest tortillas in the testing group. While we were perfectly happy with the results, the pressing process itself wasn’t our favorite. The thick, wooden plates were awkward to grip and separate, and the handle kept falling down every time we opened the press. This slowed down the pressing to 30 seconds per tortilla as compared to the 10 seconds of the winning press. We would be happy to work with this press again, but it was also so large that it would be difficult to store. At the end of the day, we would prefer to use one of the other top-rated models.
As compared to the cast-iron and wooden models, the aluminum HIC 6-Inch Tortilla Press simply couldn’t compete. It was lightweight and flimsy, and it required an excessive amount of pressure to press the dough into a flat tortilla. We weren’t able to make tortillas anywhere near as thin as the winning press, and the resulting disc was thicker on one side if we didn't rotate the tortilla and press it a second time. All in all, we’d much rather spend a few extra bucks on a better quality press.
Like the other aluminum presses, the Imusa 8-Inch Aluminum Tortilla Press wasn’t our favorite. We appreciated the 8-inch pressing surface, which prevented the dough from squeezing out the sides if it wasn't perfectly centered, but this lightweight press required so much pressure that we thought we might snap the handle! When the tortillas all turned out uneven, we knew we had to pass on this one.
If we weren’t thrilled with the other aluminum presses, we certainly weren’t impressed with the Norpro 6-Inch tortilla maker. It created thick, uneven tortillas that took a lot of pressure to create. The tortillas didn’t taste or look great, so we'd rather avoid using this model in the future.
Our team is here for one purpose: to help you buy the best stuff and love what you own. Our writers, editors, and lab technicians obsess over the products we cover to make sure you're confident and satisfied. Have a different opinion about something we recommend? Email us and we'll compare notes.