Skip to main content

Circulon A1 12-Inch ScratchDefense Nonstick Frying Pan

This durable nonstick pan boasts an ergonomic design, slick nonstick interior, and durable build. But its never-scratch claim is exaggerated.

$41.99 from Amazon

$59.99 from Target

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Durable build

  • Great nonstick performance

  • Metal utensil safe

Cons

  • "Never scratch" promise is exaggerated

  • Not broiler-safe

Seared salmon in Circulon ScratchDefense skillet, surrounded by metal utensils and a Reviewed checkmark.

review

Circulon claims its nonstick pan won't scratch—ever. Challenge accepted

Read more
Eggs frying in an OXO nonstick pan on a stovetop.

The Best Right Now

The Best Nonstick Pans

Read more

Buying Guides

Three different refrigerators standing against a brick wall

The Best Refrigerators: A Complete Guide

Read more
One robot vacuum and mop cleans a black and white checkered floor with graphic water lines

The Best Robot Vacuums and Mops

Read more
A dishwasher with three racks stands open in a kitchen

The Best Dishwashers

Read more
Amazon Echo, Google Audio, and Sonos smart speakers sit next to each other on a blue background

The Best Smart Speakers

Read more
One of the best top-load washers that we've tested is a GE Profile

The Best Top-Load Washing Machines

Read more
Four bird feeders in blue and green shades sit in a group on a brown table with a garden and green grass in the background

The Best Smart Bird Feeders

Read more
Close-up of the cooktop on a stainless steel induction range.

The Best Induction Ranges

Read more
A profile shot of tester John Higgins wearing the Sony WF-1000XM5 in public.

The Best Wireless Earbuds

Read more
View all of our buying guides