Skip to main content
DEAL WATCH: Keurig K-Express | 22% off $69.99

Keurig has changed the face of coffee, and snagging one of these for less than $70 is a solid deal. Read Review

BUY NOW
  • Introduction

  • Product Tour

  • Color & Noise Performance

  • Motion & Sharpness Performance

  • Low Light Performance

  • Compression & Media

  • Manual Controls

  • Still Features

  • Handling & Use

  • Playback & Connectivity

  • Audio & Other Features

  • JVC GZ-HM400 Comparison

  • Panasonic HDC-TM300 Comparison

  • Sony HDR-XR520V Comparison

  • Conclusion

  • Photo Gallery

  • Specs and Ratings

  • Introduction
  • Product Tour
  • Color & Noise Performance
  • Motion & Sharpness Performance
  • Low Light Performance
  • Compression & Media
  • Manual Controls
  • Still Features
  • Handling & Use
  • Playback & Connectivity
  • Audio & Other Features
  • JVC GZ-HM400 Comparison
  • Panasonic HDC-TM300 Comparison
  • Sony HDR-XR520V Comparison
  • Conclusion
  • Photo Gallery
  • Specs and Ratings

Introduction

What you do get is 64GB of internal flash memory (twice that of its predecessor), an extra level of image stabilization, and compatibility with Canon's RA-V1 LANC adapter (see Connectivity section). These are certainly useful features, but they might not warrant a race to the stores for the HF S11.

Update: The Vixia HF S11 was ultimately selected as our 2009 runner-up for Camcorder of the Year. To see why we selected it and read about our other 2009 awards, check out the 2009 CamcorderInfo.com Select Awards.

Product Tour

 

**Lens & Imaging System**


 

If you were expecting Canon to upgrade its lens or imaging system, prepare to be disappointed. The HF S11 features the exact same 10x optical, f/1.8 Canon lens and the same 1/2.6-inch CMOS sensor as the Canon HF S10 and Canon HF S100, released earlier this year. Fortunately, both lens and sensor offered excellent performance on the earlier models. If there is a difference in performance with the old and the new, it will be a result of internal processing—not lens or sensor.

 

**Front**


 

**Right**


 

**Back**


Left


 

 

**Top**


 

**Bottom**


 

**In the Box**


Color & Noise Performance

 

**Color***(8.35)*


The Canon HF S11 produced accurate colors in our bright light testing, but its results weren't as good as some of the other top-of-the-line camcorders on the market. The camcorder managed a color error of 4.19 and a saturation level of 83.64% in this test. (More on how we test color.)

Shooting in auto mode, the HF S11 had trouble rendering most colors with the ideal level of accuracy. The Color Error Map above shows the camcorder was most accurate with certain blue tones, while pinks and yellows gave it some serious trouble. Despite these troubles, the camcorder did a satisfactory job, which is what we expect from a high-end model like the HF S11.

The HF S11, like all Canons, offers a variety of color modes. In addition to the preset options (shown above), the camcorder also has a custom setting that allows you to set your own values for Color Depth, Sharpness, Contrast, and Brightness—albeit with very limited incremental control. In our testing, we found the camcorder produced the most accurate colors when using the Vivid setting: 4.06 color error, 93.57% saturation.

A camcorder's color reproduction is often a matter of personal preference. The Canon HF S11 tended to have less saturated colors than both the JVC GZ-HM400 and Panasonic TM300—something that many consumers may find disappointing. In particular, the Canon produced lighter blue tones than the competition.

Of the camcorders shown both above and below, the JVC and Panasonic had the best color accuracy, though the results were not a great deal better than those produced by the HF S11 and the Sony HDR-XR520V.

When you really get down to it, the color differences between these powerhouse camcorders are very subtle. The four camcorders shown above do an above average job at capturing colors faithfully and each of them produces a crisp, vivid image in bright light. What really separates these cameras is low light video performance, which we discuss later in this review.

 

 

**Noise***(8.33)*


The HF S11's noise percentage of 0.7225% in bright light is pretty good, but it is also slightly higher than what we got from the competition, particularly the Panasonic TM300 and Sony XR520V. Of course, noise is not usually very noticeable in bright light, as the crops below demonstrate. (More on how we test noise.)

It's nearly impossible to see any noise on the 100% crop images shown above. This is mainly because all the camcorders shown produced very little noise in our bright light testing. The crops do, however, show differences in sharpness, with the JVC GZ-HM400 managing a slight edge over the competition. Of course, every one of these camcorders is capable of capturing a very sharp image when shooting under ideal lighting conditions.

One small detail worth noting: the Canon HF S11 produced an odd dark at the top and bottom of the brown patch in the crop above. In a few other areas of the chart, the Canon seemed to have trouble rendering sudden transitions between two highly contrasting colors. The HM400 also had this trouble in places, though to a lesser degree. In fact, all four camcorders showed a bit of artifacting and splotchiness in the darker color areas.

 

 

Motion & Sharpness Performance

Low Light Performance

 

**Low Light Sensitivity***(2.77)*


The Canon HF S11 needed 17 lux of light to reach 50 IRE on our waveform monitor. This isn't a terrible performance, but it's certainly disappointing, especially considering many of last year's camcorders did better. These results seem to continue a trend we've been seeing all year: higher pixel counts mean far better sharpness in bright light, but far worse sensitivity in low light. Canon definitely isn't alone with its poor low light sensitivity; the Sony HDR-XR520V came in at 16 lux and the JVC GZ-HM400 was even worse. (More on how we test low light sensitivity.)

On the bright side, the HF S11 fared much better in low light when we used its 24p and 30p shooting modes. In fact, using these modes improved the camcorder's low light sensitivity by more than 50%. The Panasonic HDC-TM300 had the best overall low light sensitivity of the camcorders in this set, requiring only 9 lux in its regular 60i frame rate.

 

**Low Light Color***(7.23)*


The Canon HF S11 put up average numbers in our low light color testing for a high-end consumer HD camcorder. Its color error was measured at 5.06 with a saturation level of 64.79%. This represents a significant drop from the camcorder's bright light color results. (More on how we test low light color.)

The HF S11 did slightly better when we switched over to its 24p mode (5.09 color error, 77.93% saturation) and its 30p mode (5.15 color error, 75.26% saturation). The difference between the frame rates is reflected in the chart below.

The HF S11's low light color performance is on par with the Panasonic HDC-TM300 and the Sony HDR-XR520V. Interestingly, the Canon produced the darkest image of the bunch (see below), although that says more about its auto exposure system than its color accuracy. In fact, we were impressed than the camcorder produced such vivid colors despite the darkness of the footage. The color of the HF S11's footage looked quite good, especially next to the comparatively dull and washed out colors of the HM400.

While the Panasonic, Canon, and Sony each put up similar numbers in our low light color test, the JVC GZ-HM400 was the odd cam out. Its low light image was murky, noisy, discolored (with a slight green tint), and lacked vivid color saturation. It is, by far, the worst low light camcorder of the four shown above.

 

 

**Low Light Noise***(9.90)*


The noise levels on the HF S11 were pretty good in low light. The camcorder averaged 1.1325% noise in this test, which is far better than the JVC GZ-HM400, and a bit worse than both the Panasonic HDC-TM300 and Sony HDR-XR520V. (More on how we test low light noise.)

The crops above do a very good job showing off the low light capabilities of each camcorder. The HF S11 is darker than the competition, but also has a pleasantly clear image. The JVC GZ-HM400 has a very noticeable amount of noise, plus it sports a green hue that seems to take over the footage in low light. All that noise might be a result of a big boost in gain, but the Panasonic HDC-TM300 and Sony HDR-XR520V both manage to look just as bright without all that noise.

As we saw in our low light color test, the camcorder did show improved performance when we tested it using the 24p (0.95% noise) and 30p (1.1% noise) frame rates. These frame rates result in much brighter footage, while still maintaining low noise levels. Of course, bear in mind that these frame rates also impact motion significantly.

 

Compression & Media

 

**Compression***(7.0)*


As with all high definition flash memory camcorders, the Canon HF S11 records video using the AVCHD codec. Though AVCHD started out as a proprietary Sony/Panasonic compression method, it's now the chosen format for Canon and JVC as well. That means that AVCHD is more common and, therefore, more widely compatible with video editing programs. However, it still requires a powerful computer to manage the files—AVCHD files are much more processor-intensive than HDV files. If you're considering making a transition from standard definition or HDV, make sure your computer can handle it first.

With the announcement of last year's HF11, Canon became the first manufacturer to produce a consumer camcorder that recorded at a 24Mbps bitrate—the maximum bitrate allowed by the AVCHD codec. The latest models from Canon continue this trend, with the HF S11 offering two 1920 x 1080 recording at either 17Mbps or 24Mbps.

**Media***(9.42)*


The HF S11 offers very few upgrades over the HF S10 released earlier this year. One of those upgrades is recording media: the HF S11 has 64GB of internal flash memory—twice that offered by the HF S10. With 64GB of internal memory, you can record about six hours of the maximum quality footage. If you buy some SD/SDHC memory cards, you can extend that to about three additional hours per 32GB card. That's a lot of footage, even for a long vacation or a wedding.

 

We like flash memory a lot, especially when it's built into the camcorder. Flash memory has no moving parts, so it's a bit more rugged than hard drives. It's also more reliable than memory cards, which take a beating every time they're swapped in and out of the camcorder or thrown in a camera bag. Flash memory might not be up to the huge capacities offered by some hard drives, but you can fit an awful lot of footage on the HF S11. A table of approximate record times follows.

 

**Editing***(7.0)*


The Canon HF S11 comes with too many discs. If you're easily intimidated by technology, the four discs that ship with this camcorder might set your head spinning. There's the 'transfer utility' disc, the 'video tools' disc, the 'video software' disc, and the instruction manual. The latter might be self-explanatory, but you'll probably spend too much time figuring out what the other three are.

Our suggestion is to slog through installing all three. When you first plug the HF S11 into your computer, you'll probably also have to install a driver, which Windows will hopefully help you do. Once all this has been completed, you're ready to try out ImageMixer 3 SE.

 

The most important task handled by ImageMixer is transferring your files from the camcorder to your computer. You can't simply drag and drop AVCHD files. This program, however, makes the transfer process very easy (see screenshot below). This is especially easy when you're working with internal memory camcorders that should be backed up from time to time. ImageMixer also allows you to transfer footage from your computer back onto your camcorder.

 

The Editing/Authoring portion of ImageMixer is a little more complicated to use, but it has several options that intermediate video editors will welcome. You can adjust the volume of your video, add your own audio files, add text/titles, or do some basic splicing and trimming.

Though ImageMixer is at the heart of the HF S11's software, it also comes with a separate photo viewer/editor and a program for transferring your own audio files onto the camcorder (for use with playlists and Video Snap).

 

Manual Controls

 

**Auto Mode***(9.22)*


Whether you're loaning your camcorder to someone less technically inclined or just don't have the time or patience to frame a shot manually, the HF S11's auto mode will come in handy. Unfortunately, finding easy mode isn't all that easy. The HF S11's dedicated auto mode is Dual Shot mode, which is represented on the mode dial by a green icon of a camera and a camcorder. We handed the camcorder to several random passersby and not one identified this as the easy mode. We hope that next year's upgrades from Canon will address this irritating design flaw.

Users that experiment with this Dual Shot mode will be rewarded with a very straightforward recording experience. All menus and manual controls are hidden away and just about the only thing you can do is zoom, record, and press the shutter button to take photos. If you find this mode a bit too streamlined, you can also switch back to regular video mode in order to gain access to some options. Thankfully, you can keep most controls automated and still have access to the one or two manual controls you want.

As for how the HF S11 handles automatic controls, we found most adjustments to be more than adequate. Like its predecessors, the HF S11 has two autofocus modes. The first is called Instant AF—a mode that utilizes a secondary autofocus sensor (located beneath the lens) to provide an immediate, snap-like focus. Instant AF seemed to work well in most cases, but it can be finicky if there's a lot of motion in your frame. For a more traditional autofocus style, there's the normal AF system. With this system, autofocus still works quickly when moving between multiple subjects, but it doesn't have the same immediate, locked-in focus shift that occurs with instant AF. The normal AF mode looks a little more natural—almost like someone is performing a manual focus with a lens ring.

The HF S11 also features the same excellent auto exposure as the rest of the Canon lineup. The camcorder adjusts to various light sources with gradual ease. Strangely, there are multiple metering methods in still mode, but only one auto exposure setting is present for videos.

For a little extra help with focus and exposure, the HF S11 has face detection. When this feature is activated, the camcorder will automatically detect faces within the video frame and adjust focus and exposure accordingly. During playback, any clips shot using face detection can also be organized and sorted based on whose face is in the clip. Canon claims their face detection can isolate up to 9 faces at once and 35 faces in all, but we couldn't get the HF S11 to pick up more than a few faces at any given time.

There are a number of white balance presents on the camcorder, but it's the auto white balance that many beginners will rely upon. Fortunately, the auto white balance works surprisingly well in a variety of lighting conditions. Even so, the adjustments made in auto mode are never quite as accurate as those effected by a manual white balance.

Rounding out the auto controls is an auto slow shutter feature that can be turned on and off in the camcorder's menu. Turning the feature on allows the camcorder to use shutter speeds down to 1/30 of a second, which will produce a blurry, trailing effect in low light. With auto slow shutter off, the HF S100 won't drop below a 1/60 of a second shutter speed.

Low Light Modes

The HF S11 boasts only a small handful of upgrades from the HF S10 and HF S100 released earlier this year. One of those is the addition of a low light scene mode, which drops the shutter speed to as low as 1/2 of a second. There's also a Night Scene mode, which keeps the gain low and the shutter speed relatively high. This is more appropriate for shooting a city skyline at night. And in case you need that little bit of extra help when shooting in the dark, there is a built-in video light.

Scene Modes

The HF S11 has the usual set of scene modes, with the single addition of Low Light mode. The full list of available options is as follows: Portrait, Sports, Snow, Beach, Sunset, Night Scene, Low Light, Spotlight, and Fireworks. This is a decent amount of scene modes, and both the Panasonic HDC-TM300 and Sony HDR-XR520V have a similar array.

**Zoom***(6.5)*


The HF S11 has the same flat slider switch that we saw on the HF S100 earlier this year. It's an upgrade over the smaller, thinner zoom slider that we saw on last year's models. This more robust slider has an excellent level of resistance and texture to maximize the user's control. Each end of the slider has a small raised lip to improve grip more. This makes it even easier to use changes in finger pressure to achieve variable zoom speeds. The HF S11 also has secondary zoom controls in the form of membrane buttons on the LCD panel. These buttons, however, can only produce one fixed zoom speed.

The HF S11 also features a zoom speed setting that will maintain the zoom at one of three fixed speeds. The setting you choose will impact both the membrane buttons and the primary slider control. Using the slowest zoom speed setting, it takes roughly 22 seconds to go from wide angle to a full 15x zoom. With the fastest speed setting, the same zoom takes roughly 6 seconds.

**Zoom Ratio***(3.77)*


The Canon HF S11 sports a modest 10x optical zoom—the same as the HF S10 and HF S100 before it. That's less than the 12x optical zoom from last year's Canon HF11 or this year's top-of-the-line models from Sony and Panasonic. The Sanyo VPC-HD2000 tops out at 10x, but that is to be expected with its comparatively short lens barrel.

Also conspicuously absent from the HF S11 is any kind of advanced zoom feature, which many manufacturers claim can digitally expand a zoom range without image degradation. Advanced zoom seems to be a big trend in 2009, making its way into flagship models from Sony, Sanyo, and Samsung. It's present in Canon's standard definition series this year, but hasn't yet been incorporated into the high definition models.

As on most camcorders, the HF S11 also has a digital zoom option, which can be capped off at 0x, 40x, or 200x. Using digital zoom will severely decrease image quality, so we recommend leaving that cap at 0x.

New this year to Canon's high definition lineup is a tele-converter option, which magnifies your image an additional 1.7x—an effect similar to that of a tele-converter lens. This feature, however, is a digital image effect, which lowers the effective pixel count from 6.01 megapixels to 2.07 megapixels. The minimum zoom with tele-converter on is 1.7x, while the maximum is 17x.

 

**Focus***(7.5)*


Manual focus is only as useful as the ring, dial, joystick, or buttons used to operate it. On previous generation Canons, manual focus was controlled via a joystick that enabled you to select one of several focal increments on a vague scale from 'man' to 'mountain.' For this year's flagship models, Canon took a page right out of Sony's book to add a small manual control dial at the front of the camcorder. The design is startlingly similar, but we see nothing wrong in adopting a feature that works so well.

 

You can still adjust focus with the joystick and a handful of hard focal increments, but we doubt anyone would actually choose that method on purpose. The custom control dial lets you assign one of five different operations to the smooth, easy action of a dial. The dial may not significantly improve some other controls, but it is certainly a far superior method for adjusting focus.

The HF S11 also has a rudimentary focus assist, which zooms in on the center of your frame every time manual focus is engaged. Like the HF S10 before it, the HF S11 also has a surprising array of options for peaking. This tool highlights sharp edges in a bold color, helping you determine when your image is most in focus. Manual control aficionados should love this option... and these top-of-the-line 2009 models are the only consumer camcorders from Canon to include peaking. On the HF S11, peaking is available in three different colors (red, blue, and yellow) and can be displayed with a color image or in black and white. When peaking is combined with focus assist and the smooth dial control, the HF S11 offers an impressive interface for focus adjustment.

If you want to turn peaking on and off quickly, you can assign it to the custom control dial, but this will mean removing manual focus from the control dial. It's probably best to just settle on your peaking preferences and leave the dial for making accurate and precise focus adjustments.

**Exposure***(8.3)*


Like all high definition Canon camcorders, the HF S11 offers a simple exposure tool. However, the twenty-three increments (from -11 to +11) are more than you usually find on the competition. You can make the exposure adjustment through the joystick guide or opt to use the custom control dial.

The exposure tool is actually more accessible than the HF S11's shutter speed and aperture adjustments. That might serve as some consolation for the fact that shutter and aperture cannot be controlled independently.

**Aperture***(6.5)*


For videophiles that crave a full set of manual controls, Canon comes up short in one major department. Aperture adjustment is possible only in Aperture Priority mode; shutter speed only in Shutter Priority. That means that changing the aperture causes an automatic shutter speed adjustment, and vice versa.

Canon does try to make up for this by offering a wide range of aperture options and an excellent display mechanism for the feature (see animation above). While in Aperture Priority mode, you may not be able to select shutter speed, but you can manually adjust exposure and the auto gain limit. For some users, this maintains plenty of control in the user's hands; others may find it a deal-breaker.

 

**Shutter Speed***(6.6)*


Just as aperture is adjusted in Aperture Priority mode, shutter speed is adjusted only in Shutter Priority mode. Again, this means that you don't have independent control over aperture and shutter speed. The wide range of shutter speeds extends down to 1/8 (or 1/6 in 24p mode). Many camcorders don't allow you to select a shutter speed below 1/30 of a second, but the Canon HF S11 offers two very slow shutter options (1/8 and 1/15 of a second). In fact, the options actually go all the way down to 1/2 of a second, but those shutter speeds are only selected automatically in Low Light scene mode.

When adjusting shutter speed, remember that slow shutter speeds can really change the way motion looks, adding a lot of trailing and blurring. If you're shooting in dim conditions, you may want to keep it in Shutter Priority mode to prevent the camcorder from automatically selecting a very low speed. If the automatic aperture adjustment doesn't get you enough brightness, you can always use exposure to compensate.

 

**White Balance***(9.5)*


The white balance settings are exactly the same as what we reported on the Canons we reviewed earlier this year. You can select from one of the presets or perform a manual white balance. Canon always offers a good range of presets: auto, daylight, shade, cloudy, tungsten, fluorescent, and fluorescent H. This is a good showing, especially compared to camcorders from Sony or Sanyo. The manual white balance is easy to perform and usually does a good job of compensating for different color temperatures.

 

**Gain***(3.5)*


The HF S10 and HF S100 were the first consumer camcorders from Canon to offer some degree of gain control. Even so, the AGC Limit (auto gain control limit) feature is quite limited. Rather than boosting gain, AGC Limit allows the user to limit the maximum gain automatically enacted for a given scene. If you're shooting in bright light, AGC Limit is unlikely to impact your image at all. In low light, you can use this option to decrease noise. Of course, this will also prevent the HF S11 from automatically boosting gain, which could result in much darker footage. Since most consumer models do not allow you to alter the camcorder's automatic gain, we do our low light testing with the AGC Limit set to auto.

The AGC Limit control is buried fairly deep in the administrative menu, but it is also one of the five options you can assign to the custom control dial. In most circumstances, you can probably just set the AGC Limit for your current scenario and use the dial for something like focus that you might want to change on the fly.

**Color & Image Controls***(9.0)*


The Image Effects feature in the Function menu allows you to select from one of four preset options that slightly shift the appearance of your footage: vivid, neutral, low sharpening, and soft skin detail. (See below for side-by-side comparisons of the four presets.)

A fifth image effect option is Custom, which gives you manual control over color depth, sharpness, contrast, and brightness. This lets the user fine-tune the recorded image, but it's actually a very limited tool. The range for each option is only +/- 1, despite the appearance of a scale with many increments. With Canon already providing such a robust manual control experience in the HF S11, this is a disappointing deficiency.

The x.v. Color feature lets the camcorder record in the expanded xvYCC color gamut. Video recorded in this setting will only look different when played back on a television that supports xvYCC—otherwise the colors will look exactly the same.

 

 

 

**Other Manual Controls***(3.5)*


 

 

 

Still Features

 

**Still Features***(12.21)*


The HF S11 has the same extensive set of still features as the other top-of-the-line camcorders from Canon. It can capture 8-megapixel still photos natively (at a resolution of 3264 x 2456) and offers numerous smaller photo resolution options. In comparison, the JVC GZ-HM400 can take native 9-megapixel photos, the Panasonic HDC-TM300 hovers around 7 megapixels, and the Sony HDR-XR520V can capture 6-megapixel photos natively.

 

In addition to its photo size options, the HF S11 also has a built-in flash, three metering modes (evaluative, center-weighted, and spot), and a couple of continuous shooting options. The continuous shooting modes can be set to normal, which takes 3 photos per second, or high-speed, which does 5 photos per second. Both modes can take up to 60 photos in a row if you hold down the shutter button. There's also Auto Exposure Bracketing on the HF S11 that takes three photos at three different exposure levels (dark, normal, and light in 1/2 EV steps). This is a high level of sophistication for any consumer camcorder.

 

You can capture photos in any of the camcorder's shooting modes—Dual Shot, video mode, or still mode. Still mode obviously gets you the most photo options, while Video Mode only allows you to capture still images at a 3264 x 1840 or 1920 x 1080 resolution (to match the 16:9 aspect ratio of HD video). In Dual Shot mode, photo size is more of a mystery: you don't have access to the camcorder's menus, so photos are captured in the size that was last set in still mode. That means that you can be recording video one moment, then be capturing maximum resolution 4:3 photos the next. We wish this weren't so confusing in Dual Shot, but we also wish you had this degree of flexibility in regular video mode.

In photo playback, you can use the zoom toggle to digitally magnify your still photos up to 5x. You can also cycle through your photos, view them as thumbnails, start a slideshow, and delete photos— either individually in groups. The camcorder has direct to printer options and photos can be captured from a recorded movie as a sequence (up to 100 photos) or as single images.

 

**Still Color***(9.04)*


The HF S11 put up slightly better numbers in our still color testing than in our bright light video color test. The camcorder earned a color error of 3.87 with a saturation level of 93.7%. These are certainly good scores, but the three other camcorders we used as comparison models all were better. Topping the charts was the Panasonic HDC-TM300, which managed a 2.65 color error. (More on how we test still color.)

All the camcorders shown below have above-average still image capabilities and their excellent color performances show off this fact. Both the JVC and Panasonic models show more color depth than the Canon and Sony, but all the camcorders render strong colors in their digital photographs. The Canon does appear a bit washed out due to its higher automatic exposure level, but this can be manually adjusted to your liking.

 

**Still Noise***(2.28)*


The HF S11 averaged 1.06% noise in our still image testing, which is a disappointing score. Unfortunately, this also seems to be a common trend; most of the high-end camcorders we've tested have done poorly with with still noise. The JVC GZ-HM400 had 1.14% noise and the Sony HDR-XR520V had 1.07%. The Panasonic HDC-TM300 (0.79%) is one of the few flagship camcorders to have good still noise scores this year. (More on how we test still noise.)

**Still Sharpness***(12.24)*


Still sharpness is the most important still image test because it lets you know how much detail and how crisp of an image your camcorder will be able to capture in a photograph. The Canon HF S11 did fantastic in this test, measuring a horizontal sharpness of 2886 lw/ph with 5.2% oversharpening and a vertical sharpness of 1477 lw/ph with 6% undersharpening. (More on how we test still sharpness.)

The Canon even outscored the JVC GZ-HM400 in this test, despite the fact that the JVC has a higher effective pixel count for still images (9 megapixels vs. 8 megapixels). The Panasonic and Sony, while still having decent sharpness scores, were well behind the Canon and JVC. One reason we do this test is to show that camcorders are rarely capable of producing actual line widths per picture height (lw/ph) that match the resolution of the image. So, even though the Canon HF S11 is capable of taking still photos at a 3264 x 2456 resolution, its sharpness isn't nearly that high.

 

Handling & Use

Playback & Connectivity

 

**Playback***(6.15)*


The HF S11 has the same playback system as all of Canon's 2009 HD camcorders. The LCD panel contains a button that allows you to switch into a dedicated playback mode, which brings up a series of thumbnails. Using the zoom toggle allows you to control how many thumbnails are displayed at once—either 15 or 6 at a time. Selecting an image with the joystick button allows you to play it back as a full-screen video (or full-screen still image). You can switch between video and photo playback without swapping modes on the dial.

 

VCR playback controls are split between the LCD panel and the joystick button. Play/pause, stop, and playlist are all on the LCD panel and are large, clearly marked, and easy to use. Fast-forward, rewind, slow-motion, and playback volume are all awkwardly mapped to the joystick. This isn't a simple click to the left or right; you have to push down on the button, then move it left or right to select the option you want. Simply put, this is not a good system.

The playback menu offers a few simple editing and organization features. Clips can be divided, organized by date, or grouped according to people's faces that are located in the videos themselves (if footage was recorded using the face detection feature). You can also capture still photos from your recorded video by pressing the shutter button when your video is paused. The still image playback menu offers options for rotating, printing, organizing, and deleting your photos.

The playlist function on the HF S11 lets you group a selection of videos or images to be played back in a particular order. It's similar to making a mix CD or slideshow—clips can be arranged and organized without regard to the date they were captured or the order in which they were filmed. You can even add background music to your playlists by importing your own tunes onto the camcorder or using the Music CD provided by Canon.

This can also be done when using the special Video Snap feature. Video Snap is essentially the same as a music-accompanied playlist, but videos are constrained to four seconds each, making for a sort of manic flurry of short clips.

 

 

**Connectivity***(5.88)*


The connectivity options on the HF S11 are essentially identical to the Canon HF S100 and HF S10—with one notable exception. The HF S11 is compatible with Canon's newly released RA-V1 remote adapter, which plugs into the camcorder's accessory shoe and gives the camcorder a LANC (wired remote) terminal. The RA-V1 is sold separately for $120 and does add a significant bulk to the top of the camcorder.

 

There's also been some discussion as to whether the RA-V1 is compatible with older models. We tested it with the HF S10, HF S100, and HF20 and found that the camcorder recognizes the RA-V1 and allows you to attach a wired remote. However, Canon has informed us that the RA-V1 has been known to cause audio frequency interference in older Canon models, particularly when using an external microphone. If you plan to use the LANC controller and an external microphone, we recommend you do so only with the Canon HF S11.

The ports on the HF S11 are located in a number of different places. On the right side of the camcorder, behind the hand strap, is a plastic door that tilts open to reveal a Component-out, USB, and HDMI port. The placement of these ports are a bit annoying, as they can be difficult to access behind the thick hand strap. Also, the port cover doesn't open very far.

 

Two more ports are located on the back of the camcorder: the AV/headphone-out port and the DC-input. Both of these terminals feature their own, dedicated port covers that are tethered to the body of the camcorder. These covers feel quite strong and do match the body of the camcorder very well. They can sometimes get in the way, however, particularly when you have cables connected to both ports simultaneously.

 

Inside the LCD cavity is the camcorder's SD/SDHC memory card slot. The slot is well protected by a hard piece of plastic that folds down towards the bottom of the camcorder. This design does make it difficult (or impossible) to swap out memory cards when the HF S11 is mounted to a tripod.

 

We discussed the camcorder's Mini Advanced accessory shoe earlier in this section. From what we can tell, the shoe is identical in every way to Canon's previous Mini Advanced accessory shoes, and its placement is the same as on the Canon HF S100 and HF S10. The shoe is protected by a sliding piece of hard plastic that provides adequate protection.

 

 

Audio & Other Features

 

**Audio Features***(5.75)*


The Canon HF S11 has the same audio features as Canon's previous high-end camcorders, the HF S100 and HF S10. For starters, it includes a 3.5mm external mic input near the front of the camcorder (on the right side) and an AV-output that can double as a headphone jack. These are important features that are must-haves for any high-end consumer camcorder. Unfortunately, the mic jack has no port covering whatsoever, which leaves it fully exposed to the elements. It is well-placed, though, so at least you don't have to contend with annoying cables when you connect a mic to the camcorder.

The HF S11 has a Dolby Digital 2-channel microphone that isn't particularly well-placed, but it is better than some of the top-mounted mics we saw on models from Panasonic and JVC. The HF S11's mic is located on both sides of the camcorder, near the very front of the lens. Wandering fingers can definitely find their way into rubbing up against this side-mounted mic placement, particularly when you use the custom control dial on the left (located just beneath the mic). On the right side, the mic is more out of the way, even if you have large hands.

Like Canon's other camcorders, the HF S11 has a manual audio level adjustment option. When adjusting audio, there is no numeric or incremental display of how much you are raising or lowering the levels. Instead, a small line in the lower left of the LCD expands and contracts  as you raise and lower the audio levels (almost as if you're turning a volume knob). Still, the manual audio adjustment is a terrific feature to have. The camcorder includes an audio level display with markers for -40dB, -12dB, and 0dB. By checking out the display you can figure out where your audio is peaking and adjust levels accordingly.

There are a number of additional audio features on the HF S11 that the casual videographer is likely to ignore. There's an audio test tone that can be used for calibration or testing audio equipment, a microphone attenuator that can be engaged to limit audio levels, and a wind cut feature for reducing noise associated with rustling wind. The HF S11 has Canon's proprietary Mini Advanced accessory shoe that is protected by a sliding cover on top of the camcorder. This is the same accessory shoe as featured on all of Canon's consumer HD camcorders—except for the Canon HV40, which has a regular-sized shoe.

 

**Other Features***(4.5)*


*Digital Effects
*The HF S11 has a few digital effects: black & white, sepia, and art. The camcorder also has a regular fade feature and a wipe fade. All these effects are found in the function menu and can be activated using the joystick menu once they are selected.

Video Light

The video light is a bit hidden on the HF S11. It is located on the top of the camcorder, in front of the accessory shoe. When you turn on the light from the joystick menu (or activate the flash, which is located in the same spot), it pops up from its underground lair to provide you with lovely illumination. The light isn't fantastic and it will eat up your battery life, but its good to have if you do lots of filming in the dark.

Pre-Record

Pre-record is a useful new feature on this year's Canons. When the setting is turned on, the camcorder will constantly record footage in a 3-second memory buffer. This means, whenever you press record you've already captured three seconds of video. Pre-record can be very useful if you're recording a sporting event or trying to capture an unpredictable event. Like the video light, pre-record does use up a lot of battery power, so don't turn it on if you're going to be away from a power source for a long time.
*

Video Snapshot*

Video Snapshot is also new to this year's Canons, but it doesn't do all that much. When you press the Video Snap button, a blue border appears around the LCD screen that will begin to illuminate when you press the record button. After roughly 4 seconds, the blue border will have made its way around the entirety of the LCD screen and recording will automatically cease. Essentially, the video snapshot feature is useful for making short 4-second clips one at a time. These clips can then be organized in a playlist, have music added to them, and viewed as a short little film on the camcorder.

 

JVC GZ-HM400 Comparison

The GZ-HM400 is an interesting new entry from JVC, presenting significant performance improvements over the HD300 and provided a much fuller feature set than the X900. This is the camcorder for more serious videophiles and it is actually worthy competition for the Canon HF S11. In fact, the HM400 outpaced the HF S11 in all the bright light testing, proving itself to be a powerhouse of color accuracy and sharp, smooth footage.

Unfortunately, this was only true when recording in ideal conditions. In low light, the HM400 really floundered, capturing incredibly dark images riddled with a haze of noise and washed out colors. If you plan to shoot in dimmer lighting, the HF S11 is no champion, but it fared much better than the flagship from JVC. The Canon also provides the user with 24p and 30p frame rate alternatives, which significantly improve low light performance.

The Canon is also a meatier choice for advanced videographers, giving users a more fleshed out array of manual controls. The new compatibility with Canon's RA-V1 LANC adapter is also sure to draw experienced users.

Where the HM400 does come out on top is in the stabilization department. Even the HF S11's new Dynamic stabilization mode can't match the testing results of the HM400, which showed significant improvement with its single optical stabilization level activated. If stabilization is important to you, the HM400 is certainly an interesting model to consider.

And what will compel most users to select the top-of-the-line JVC over its Canon counterpart? Price. A savings of $400 is considerable in this day and age. For people less interested in the bells and whistles offered by the HF S11, that may be $400 you can't turn down.

 

 

 

 

Panasonic HDC-TM300 Comparison

For the extra 32GB of internal flash memory, you'll need to pay $100 extra for the Canon HF S11. Aside from that, however, the HF S11 and the Panasonic HDC-TM300 are very similar models. They each represent the flash memory flagships from their respective manufacturers and they each offer a slew of manual controls and features to please advanced users.

Though the two models are very similar, the TM300 has a slight edge in just about every respect. It has slightly better color performance and slightly better low light performance. It is slightly more comfortable to hold and has slightly better optical image stabilization.

In some areas, it's very difficult to pick a clear winner. We think it would be hard to find a more comfortable camcorder than the TM300, but the side mounted accessory shoe is an unusual design and the HF S11 does a better job of keeping its built-in microphone hidden from stray fingers. This might be a matter of personal choice.

Another personal choice: do you prefer the cam control dial of the manual control lens ring? We have a small preference for the lens ring, which has a smoother, wider range of action. If you're using the viewfinder instead of the LCD, the features controlled by the lens ring can be swapped on the fly. Speaking of which, the TM300 has an extensible electronic viewfinder, while the Canon has only its LCD. On the other hand, the HF S11 is now compatible with Canon's RA-V1 LANC adapter. These are both features that advanced users yearn for... just remember that you have to fork over $120 for the adapter that will let you connect a wired remote to the HF S11.

For still photography, neither model is perfect. The Canon HF S11 is inferior in color and noise, but is a clear winner in sharpness. The Panasonic HDC-TM300 doesn't have as much in the way of still features, but it has more size options and no confusing Dual Shot mode.

And that brings to mind the greatest advantage that the Panasonic has over its rival from Canon. In terms of ease of use, the TM300 is light years ahead. The HF S11 has this confusing Dual Shot mode, which essentially hides auto mode from the people that would want it the most. The TM300's manual button is also tucked away, but at least the function of this button is easily understood. When in auto mode, the TM300 offers a lot more to make videography easier: the company's great iA features and a helpful info button to explain many of the menu's options. Even in manual mode, the TM300 is easier to use, with a less divided menu structure that makes it easier to find the feature you want.

More savvy users might be tempted by some of the advanced features of the Canon, but the TM300 certainly has its share as well. Perhaps more importantly, the TM300 delivers a more pleasant user experience, especially for less experienced users.

 

 

 

 

 

Sony HDR-XR520V Comparison

The Sony HDR-XR520V is more expensive than the HF S11 and is certainly much bulkier and more uncomfortable. For many consumers, those disadvantages will be outweighed by the root cause: an enormous 240GB hard-drive. That gives you practically infinite capacity. We think the 64GB of internal flash memory on the HF S11 is plenty—plus it has the advantage of being more stable than the moving parts of most hard drives.

In terms of performance, the two camcorders are roughly equivalent. It's less noisy, but also less sharp. And neither gives an impressive performance in low light. Both also rely on a small dial at the front of the camcorder for adjusting some manual controls. We do like that the XR520's dial is easier to change on the fly, but the Canon simply offers more options. There's AGC limit, shutter-priority and aperture-priority modes, 24p and 30p frame rates, and more still photography features. It's true that the Sony has a viewfinder, but we think most videographers will choose manual image controls over a viewfinder.

There is one significant advantage the XR520 has over the HF S11: an incredibly effective image stabilization system. Like the HF S11, the Sony model has two levels of stabilization, but the Sony is significantly better at reducing camera shake. The XR520 is also a little easier to use for beginners, especially thanks to some helpful tool tips.

We think this means that newer consumers will lean towards the models from Sony, but experienced users might opt for the savvy offerings from the Canon HF S11.

 

 

 

 

 

Conclusion

Specs and Ratings

{{manufacturer_specs_table}}{{raw_scores_table}}

Meet the tester

Kaitlyn Chantry

Kaitlyn Chantry

Vice President, Editorial Management

@WhyKaitlyn

Vice President of Editorial Management, Kaitlyn oversees the editorial departments of Reviewed.com’s various sites. She has been writing about technology since the turn of the century. Outside of her Reviewed.com home, Kaitlyn is also a theatre director and avid gamer.

See all of Kaitlyn Chantry's reviews

Checking our work.

Our team is here for one purpose: to help you buy the best stuff and love what you own. Our writers, editors, and lab technicians obsess over the products we cover to make sure you're confident and satisfied. Have a different opinion about something we recommend? Email us and we'll compare notes.

Shoot us an email

Up next