Credit:
Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser
The Best Beauty Subscription Boxes of 2026
Products are chosen independently by our editors. Purchases made through our links may earn us a commission.
Credit:
Reviewed / Betsey Goldwasser
Why trust Reviewed?
Reviewed's mission is to help you buy the best stuff and get the most out of what you already own. Our team of product experts thoroughly vet every product we recommend to help you cut through the clutter and find what you need.
Learn more about our product testing
Boxycharm
Boxycharm contains five, full-sized, high-end products. It includes an in-depth survey, and the products are well worth the price of subscription. Read More
Pros
- Five full-size products
- Great variety
- Includes high-end brands
Cons
- None that we could find
Allure
A great subscription box choice with eight full- and sample-size products and a great variety. Read More
Pros
- Some full-size products
- Great variety
Cons
- Not customizable
Ipsy
The Ipsy Glam Bag is a compact set of five products, ranging from store brands to other, rarer ones. Its simplicity is excellent for beginners. Read More
Pros
- Some full-size products
Cons
- Less variety
Petit Vour The Vegan Beauty Box
This cute, small subscription box offers a great variety, but not very well known brands. Read More
Pros
- Small packaging
- Great variety
- Great value
Cons
- Lesser-known brands
Dermstore
A box with 6+ full- and sample-size products that offers luxury brands you may otherwise not try. Read More
Pros
- Some full-size products
- Very high quality brands
Cons
- Not customizable
- Less variety
-
Boxycharm
-
How We Tested Beauty Subscription Boxes
-
What You Should Know About Beauty Subscription Boxes
-
Other Beauty Subscription Boxes We Tested
-
More Articles You Might Enjoy
No matter your skill level with skincare and makeup, beauty subscription boxes are a great way to learn about a variety of popular products that could become your new must-haves. For makeup and skincare junkies who love trying new products, the boxes provide that fix and keep your vanity in constant rotation with new goodies. And for those just dipping their toes into the nuances of beauty items like concealer and dry shampoo, the boxes serve as a great introduction.
The ideal beauty box subscription, at least to this beauty editor, is one that’s customizable at the time or ordering, meaning that it asks you to fill out a survey with your preferences to make sure you receive items that you’ll put to use. A great beauty box also includes a variety of products for different parts of the skincare and makeup routine (e.g., eye cream, face serum, sheet masks, bronzer, mascara). After testing seven popular subscription boxes, Boxycharm rose through the ranks as our Best Overall, with its inclusion of five full-size skincare and makeup products from a variety of high-end, drugstore, and indie brands with a total value that far exceeds the cost of the box. Ready for your new favorite beauty purchase?
These are the best beauty subscription boxes we tested ranked, in order:
- Boxycharm
- Allure Beauty Box
- Ipsy Glam Bag
- Petit Vour Vegan Beauty Box
- Dermstore Beauty Fix
- Birchbox
- Glossybox
- FabFitFun
Credit: Reviewed / Betsey GoldwasserBoxycharm offers five full-size products.
How We Tested Beauty Subscription Boxes
The Tester
Hi, I'm Jessica, the lifestyle writer and resident beauty expert at Reviewed. It should go without saying (given the nature of my job) that I’m passionate about trying out makeup, skincare, and hair care. This led me to try the winner of our previous beauty box test, the now-discontinued Play! By Sephora beauty box a few years back before I worked for Reviewed. That was my first and only time subscribing to a beauty or lifestyle box and I learned that I always looked forward to getting the products, but I’d often use them up very quickly because of the sample size amount, and then not purchase the full-size versions because of the price. For that reason, when I tested these boxes, I paid attention to which ones gave me products that I could get a lot of uses out of at a variety of prices.
The Tests
I ordered seven of the most popular beauty subscription boxes, filled out the surveys for the ones that had them, and waited for each one to arrive. Before scoring the boxes, I waited to receive two shipments (one per month) of each, so that I’d have a better idea of how the subscription looked after the initial ordering—mostly, I wanted to know that the box wouldn’t only be great for the first month because I was a new member. (This article will be updated when the second FabFitFun box, which ships quarterly, arrives.)
Reviewed’s senior scientist, Julia MacDougall, created a calibrated rubric, which I filled out upon each box’s arrival. I rated the boxes based on the following attributes:
Ordering process: How in-depth did the survey feel? Was I notified that the box would be arriving soon? How long did it take for the box to arrive?
Presentation: How nicely was the box packaged?
Variation: Were the products well-matched to my survey answers? What was the general and relative quality of the products? Were there instructions for how to use the products?
Product quality and value: Is this beauty box worth its price? How did the cost of the subscription box compare to the total retail cost of the products in the box?
Cancellation: How easy was it to cancel the beauty box subscription?
What You Should Know About Beauty Subscription Boxes
Though customization is an attribute that did not get weighted on our rubric, it’s important to document. For some companies, you’ll fill out a survey about your hair, makeup, and skincare preferences either before or right after you purchase a box. Some surveys require fewer details, asking questions about your hair and eye colors and skin type and tone, or asking whether you’re more interested in skincare, makeup, or hair care. Other surveys are very in-depth, asking for your preference in brands, how often you use particular products (like face oils or foundations), what colors you’d wear most often in certain types of products (like eyeshadow palettes or lipsticks), and more.
Some companies, whether they include a survey or not, may email you before the box ships to ask you if you want to choose a particular product from that month’s rotation at no additional cost. (To be clear, you’re not receiving an extra product—just ensuring that your box includes whichever one you select.) I never opted into customization beyond the survey because I think part of testing the service is seeing how well it chooses products for the user. When I refer to a box as “customizable,” I’m only indicating that it includes a survey.
Other Beauty Subscription Boxes We Tested
The Allure Beauty Box includes eight full- and sample-sized goodies.
The Ipsy Glam Bag comes with five full- and sample-sized items.
The Petit Vour Vegan Beauty Box offers four full- and mini-sized products.
The Dermstore Beauty Fix includes at least six full- or sample-sized products.
Birchbox includes six products in the box.
Glossybox comes with six items in full and sample sizes
FabFitFun comes with a smattering of lifestyle products.
More Articles You Might Enjoy
Meet the tester
Jessica writes and edits beauty content. She's spent years testing makeup, skincare, hair care, and body care products, and she has acted as Reviewed's beauty expert.
Jessica holds a Bachelor's degree in journalism from Emerson College, and she's written for Scary Mommy, 7News, Boston.com, Citizine, and Boston Common Magazine.
Checking our work.
Our team is here to help you buy the best stuff and love what you own. Our writers, editors, and experts obsess over the products we cover to make sure you're confident and satisfied. Have a different opinion about something we recommend? Email us and we'll compare notes.
Shoot us an email