Using a top load washer with an agitator smacks of nostalgia. If you were born in the last two or three generations, a top-loading washing machines with a pole agitator have been around for roughly a century. Your parents and grandparents used them.
Now, as a homeowner, you might just like to use one too: there's something comforting about doing household chores the same way as you saw them done while growing up. What's more, high efficiency front-load washers, though newer, still have issues with odor build-up and loud vibrations.
Time hasn’t stood still for pole-agitator models. Many use the top loader's time-tested design and improved on it with the addition of modern improvements such as stainless steel wash tubs, soft-close hinges, and dual-action agitators.
We’ve been testing washing machines in our labs for the better part of a decade. We’ve put hundreds of washers under the microscope to test how well they remove stains, their water usage, and how gentle they are on our clothing.
The Whirpool WTW8127LC(available at Lowe's) is our best traditional washing machine for its ability to blend modern features with old-school cleaning. If you're looking for a pole agitator, it's the one to buy.
These are the best top-load agitator washers we tested ranked, in order:
Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission.
How We Tested
What You Should Know About Top-Loading Agitator Washers
If you want a washer that is easy to use, provides a good clean, and has a pole agitator, the Whirlpool WTW8127LC is a solid choice.
This Lowe’s exclusive has three unique features that set it apart from the rest of the pack. First, it has a removable agitator for when you need extra space or a more gentle wash cycle. All you need to do is squeeze the handle on top of the agitator and the whole pole pops out. This top loader also comes with a built-in pretreating station—there is a faucet that can dispense hot and cold water and a specialized brush for scrubbing stubborn stains. Finally, instead of having vague cycle names, the WTW8127LC has the “What to Wash / How to Wash” system. Knowing exactly what your washer is doing to your clothes helps cut down on confusion and frustration when it comes to doing laundry.
We think a washer that has a pole agitator, a washer plate, and a utility sink is worth checking out.
We have plenty of experience testing these products in the lab, but we've also used them like normal people would in the course of their daily lives, which means that we have a great sense for what appliances are bargains at their price points, and which appliances have really useful extra features (as opposed to the kitchen-sink approach to features).
With all this in mind, you can feel confident that when we recommend a product, we're giving it our Reviewed stamp of approval, which means two things: firstly, this appliance performs well, and secondly, this appliance is easy to use. We're always reviewing new products, so stay tuned for our reviews and roundups of the latest products in laundry, refrigerators, dishwashers, and vacuum cleaners.
Every washing machine that comes into Reviewed’s labs gets put through the same testing regime, which addresses both performance and user-friendliness. Performance tests include:
• Stain removal – on a strip of AHAM-approved stains (which includes cocoa, sweat, pig’s blood, red wine, and oil), how much of each stain can this washing machine remove?
• Wear and tear – during a given cycle, how hard is the mechanical action of the washing machine on your clothes?
• Water retention – how much water does your washing machine spin out at the end of the cycle?
• Cycle time – how long is each washing machine cycle?
The best washing machines have solid stain removal abilities, do not damage your clothes, retain little water, are energy efficient, and have short cycle times.
Beyond these performance tests, we also assess the usability of each washing machine, based on our experience, both during testing and during more casual use (one perk of working at Reviewed is that there is plenty of laundry machines on premises!). Our main goal is to get the answer to one question: how easy is it to actually use this washing machine? This involves cumulatively assessing the control panel, the door, the detergent dispenser, and any smart features that are included.
By combining the performance data with our own observations, we can make solid recommendations for someone looking for any type of washing machine at any price point.
What You Should Know About Top-Loading Agitator Washers
While recent studies indicate that front-load washing machines are overtaking top-load washers in the laundry popularity contest, some shoppers prefer to stick with what they know—top-loading washing machines with pole agitators. The sentiment isn't misplaced; getting a machine similar to one whose layout and logic you're used to will make your laundry life easier, even if most top-load agitator washing machines have gotten a tech-induced face-lift, and will probably look slightly different than the one in your mom's basement.
Lastly, top-load washers have different ergonomics than front-loading washers. If you prefer to just drop laundry into the washer from a standing position, and don't want to crouch down to get your clothes into and out of a front-load washing machine (or have to stack your front-loader so that accessible while standing), then you're probably better off with a top-loader. The washing machine type and feature set are just two of the things to consider when you're buying a washing machine, but knowing that you prefer a top-load over a front-load washer will help to narrow down your choices considerably.
Other Top-Load Agitator Washers We Tested
Laundry purists may stand behind a traditional washing machine design—a top loader with a pole agitator—such as the new LG WT7305CV, but those who can also geek out on special smart features will love this modern machine.
The WT7305CV comes outfitted with LG's ThinQ app, which lets you control the washer remotely, and, through LG's ProActive Care program, it uses AI and wifi to send LG usage diagnostics and appliance problems. It also has some other great features that actually add functionality, like its soft-close lid and a deep fill feature, which is great for users who get their clothes really, really dirty.
When it comes to cleaning power, the WT7305CV holds its own, but we would've liked to see a bit more stain-fighting power from a washer in this price range. That being said, the WT7305CV is more than capable of handling the average load of laundry—just be careful around red wine and chocolate.
GE obviously has its finger on the pulse of what Americans want in a traditional top-load washing machine. The GE GTW685BSLWS has built time-tested features into a modern machine. Its soft-close glass lid is a nice bonus, and it allows you to monitor the wash as it agitates. All you need to do to turn on the machine is to lift up the lid.
A single knob lets you dial up a wash cycle; because they’re clearly labeled, it’s a breeze to pick the one you need. You can have granular control over each wash load by choosing the soil level, water temperature, spin, and rinse. Once you’ve set it, you can save it using the My Cycle feature.
Our tests didn’t show the stain guide feature to be particularly helpful on this washer. Stick with the Normal cycle, and you’ll be happier. The Deep Fill button gives you extra water when you want it.
For this top-loading agitator machine, getting clean laundry is a successful balancing act between old-school and high-tech.
The Maytag MVW7230HW top-loader carries a premium price, but if you can get it on sale it offers some decent performance for a traditional top-loader. On our tests, we found it performed about as well as the average washer and also had some nice extras like a built-in faucet and an impressive, decade-long warranty.
Want a big washer that can deal with big messes? The 5.2-cu.-ft. capacity Maytag MVW8230HC top-load washer gets the job done. With its pole agitator, smart features, stainless steel finish, and control panel that has both a dial and buttons, this Maytag washer is a great combination of old-school functionality and new tech features.
In our lab tests, we were really impressed with the stain removal power of the Heavy Duty cycle, and that’s without activating the much-touted Extra Power stain removal booster. The other cycles did a pretty good job of cleaning, but the other great part of this washer is that it was very gentle on our test loads of laundry, so it won’t wear out your clothes prematurely after several washes. If you find yourself constantly tackling really dirty laundry, you’ll appreciate the Maytag MVW8230HC washer.
The made-in-America Maytag MVWC465HW washer is perfect for people who want a traditional white top-load washing machine with an old-school pole agitator.
The PowerWash cycle does a good job removing stains, but its cycle time is a bit long, clocking in at an hour and 24 minutes. You can try the normal cycle, which has a shorter run time of 47 minutes, but your clothes might not get as clean.
This machine lets you add more water to a cycle with the "Deep Water Wash" option, and the "Deep Rinse" option sprays water on the wash drum itself, cleaning the washer of leftover detergent and stain residue, which means you're not transferring dirt from one load of laundry to another. We think this washer will work well for a smaller, cleaner family.
The Maytag MVWC565FW washer is a good value—less expensive than its sibling, the Maytag MVWB765FW, but similar in important ways.The spacious, 4.2-cu.-ft. tub lets you do a lot of laundry at once, and the central corkscrew agitator and lengthy PowerWash cycle work together to produce very clean clothes.
This model also includes a Wrinkle Control cycle (basically a Delicate cycle with warm water) that purports to help clean and mitigate wrinkles on fabrics that might be more difficult to iron, like sports jerseys or clothes made with blended fabrics.
This washer’s five knob interface won’t win any design awards, but whether you’re a laundry expert or you’ve never done a load before, you’ll find every control easy to use. The temperature settings are numerous, you can choose a deep water level for really dirty clothes, and with a turn of the dial, select whether you want one rinse or two.
If you like old-school washers, the Maytag MVWP576KW is a solid choice. It’s a straightforward commercial-grade washer with intuitive controls and an aesthetic reminiscent of the washers from a few decades ago. With a solid metal construction, this top-loader is certainly built for punishment, and its motor comes backed by a 10-year guarantee.
In terms of cleaning, the MVWP576KW didn’t impress us as much as some other Maytags have, but it should be able to handle the average load of laundry.
We’d recommend the Maytag MVWP576KW if high durability is your main concern.
The GE GTW335ASNWW is a solidly good top-loader. It might not be the greatest we’ve ever tested, but it’s a reasonable price for what it offers. If you’re just looking for an inexpensive, old-school-style washer, this one is a great pick.
Part of the GTW335ASNWW’s low price is due to its feature-light design: If you’re looking for bells and whistles, this washer isn’t for you. If you don’t want a bunch of extra features you won’t use, however, you can save some money by opting for the GTW335ASNWW.
Good cleaning performance for its price
If you're looking for top-notch cleaning, look elsewhere
Do you want a basic washing machine that is easy to use, but still has some flexibility when it comes to cycle options? If so, you’ll like the Whirlpool WTW4955HW washer. Its control panel consists of a series of dials; by adjusting the dials, you can choose different cycles or cycle options (soil level, wash temperature, water level, etc.). If you prefer adding more water to your cycles, you’ll like the Deep Water Wash option. LED lights that run along the bottom of the control panel allow you to quickly check on the cycle status.
For tough stains, we definitely recommend using the Heavy cycle; in just over an hour, it did an impressive job at getting our test laundry loads clean. Even better, though, is the fact that the Normal cycle also does a solid job at stain removal, meaning that you can rely on the Normal cycle to meet your day-to-day laundry needs. While this washer was a bit tougher on clothes than we prefer, that’s pretty common for washing machines with pole agitators. For an affordable, no-frills washer, look no further than the Whirlpool WTW4955HW.
Whirlpool makes the low-priced Roper RTW4516FW top-load washing machine with a pole agitator. It is very easy to use, and it does an okay job of cleaning your clothes. While it's gentler on your clothes than some of the other agitator washers on this list, it is relatively inefficient when it comes to water usage.
Additionally, this Roper washer doesn't do a great job of spinning the water out of the laundry at the end of the cycle; expect to be pulling wet, heavy laundry loads out of this washer. If you can, wait until you can afford a better washer.
Julia is the Senior Scientist at Reviewed, which means that she oversees (and continually updates) the testing of products in Reviewed's core categories such as televisions, washing machines, refrigerators, and more. She also determines the testing methods and standards for Reviewed's "The Best Right Now" articles.
Jonathan Chan currently serves as the Lab Manager at Reviewed. If you clean with it, it's likely that Jon oversees its testing. Since joining the Reviewed in 2012, Jon has helped launch the company's efforts in reviewing laptops, vacuums, and outdoor gear. He thinks he's a pretty big deal. In the pursuit of data, he's plunged his hands into freezing cold water, consented to be literally dragged through the mud, and watched paint dry. Jon demands you have a nice day.
We use standardized and scientific testing methods to scrutinize every product and provide you with objectively accurate results. If you’ve found different results in your own research, email us and we’ll compare notes. If it looks substantial, we’ll gladly re-test a product to try and reproduce these results. After all, peer reviews are a critical part of any scientific process.