• Logitech Pro

  • Razer BlackWidow Chroma V2

  • Other Gaming Keyboards We Tested

  • More Articles You Might Enjoy

logitech-keyboard-body
Credit: Reviewed.com / Jackson Ruckar
Best Overall
Logitech Pro

The Logitech Pro is our pick for best overall due to its combination of reliable performance, compact size, and simple, robust feature set. The "tenkeyless" Logitech Pro ditches the number pad found on the right-hand side of most keyboards in favor of a more compact design. While this makes it slightly less ideal for general/office use, it makes it easier to center equidistantly under each hand, which is better for typing and certain game layouts. You're getting fewer keys here compared to most gaming keyboards out there, but you're also essentially paying for sheer performance rather than a potentially extraneous set of keys.

It may seem odd that the smaller Pro fetches a higher price than some of the much larger—and perhaps flashier—keyboards on the list, but you're not just paying for portability here. I found the satisfyingly clicky keys boasted reliable, quick travel, and the symmetrical/center-based layout lenders typing and WASD'ing a sturdiness that first-time users should find very appealing. The Logitech Pro was far and away my favorite keyboard for general typing, and it's minimalist-looking enough that it won't offend aesthetic sensibilities if you're looking for form as well as function. At $130, it's not cheap, but it will please a wide majority of gamers.

Finally, it's by far the best choice for gamers on the go from amongst the keyboards we tested. The detachable cable and compact design make it easy to pack away and take on the road.

razer-keyboard-body
Credit: Reviewed.com / Jackson Ruckar
Best Performance
Razer BlackWidow Chroma V2

A standout member of Razer's LED-happy "CHROMA" brand, the BlackWidow is by far the priciest keyboard in our roundup, but for good reason. Not only is Razer a leader in gaming peripherals of all types, but the company also wields the advantage of branding/manufacturing proprietary keys (or "mechanical switches") for its keyboards. This means the BlackWidow Chroma is available with either "tactile and clicky," "tactile and silent," or "linear and silent," depending on the customization you favor. The company also claims that, regardless of which mechanical switch you go with, you'll get 30 million more keystrokes out of them than the standard switch.

I wish I could say that we tested millions of keystrokes, but the Zerg didn't give me a chance. A big part of the test process for each gaming keyboard (and the sister gaming mouse roundup) involved playing games, one of which was StarCraft. I'm no pro gamer, but I was a decent SC player back in the day, and the game presents an excellent opportunity to test out features related to micro/macro management and unit directive skills. The BlackWidow excelled in this area, partially due to the sheer size/key quality of the keyboard, but also due to the unique elements present in the "CHROMA" line. In fact, amongst the staggering amount of LED backlight customization options here, there's even specific settings for different games—FPS, RTS, MMO, MOBA, and StarCraft, specifically. The latter setting (pictured) automatically highlights the relevant keys to help players maximize their APM (actions per minute), which is an economical measurement (in mid- to late-game) for ensuring you aren't wasting time or resources.

But that's really just the tip of the iceberg. Where features go, the BlackWidow packs pretty much everything and the kitchen sink into its hardware and software. A handsome braided cable, multi-bracket positioning feet, five extra macro keys along the left side, USB pass-thru functionality, and even audio out/microphone jacks for the staunchest power users. This version (V2) also includes a very comfortable wrist-rest, which smartly magnetizes to the bottom of the keyboard, making it very easy to attach and remove on the fly. While there is evidence that these kinds of wrist rests are not actually good for preventing wrist fatigue or carpal tunnel, we're not complaining about its inclusion.

The BlackWidow is a serious product at around $170, but it's also the rootenest, tootenest performer amongst these keyboards, and has a huge array of special features and extras that should please gamers of all stripes. That said, if you don't need the whole kit and caboodle, there are much cheaper options that might suit your needs.

Related content

Other Gaming Keyboards We Tested

SteelSeries Apex M500

This SteelSeries mechanical gaming keyboard brings a lot to the table for the $100 asking price. The Apex M500 wields the widely praised Cherry MX Red keys and delivers a traditional size with high ramps that allow for multiple height adjustments. SteelSeries claims the Apex M500 is "built like a tank," and I'm inclined to agree. Not only was it one of the sturdier-feeling keyboards I tested, but I hammered at it while typing and desperately trying to win StarCraft matches, and it didn't flinch.

The Apex M500 features blue backlit keys, which are not only kind of gorgeous, they're a little more soothing than the standard red or greens featured by many gaming keyboards. Overall, the Apex M500 is a very good all-around choice for its sturdy build and generous real estate. It doesn't have quite the laundry list of extra features as something like the Razer BlackWidow, but it's also much more affordable, making it a great pick for a wide variety of gamers.

HyperX Alloy FPS

HyperX may not be as widely known as brands like Logitech or Razer, but the company makes some rad gaming peripherals—especially its gaming headsets. The Alloy FPS is a solid gaming keyboard: it's mechanical with a robust design, and features the same praised Cherry MX switches as the Apex 500. The handsome red-and-black cable is detachable, and you'll get the full keyboard-and-numpad experience here, too.

My time with the Alloy FPS was mostly positive, though typing proved difficult. There's a trend in gaming keyboards to provide very responsive, tall, and clicky keys. These are great for double-tap executions during games and overall precision and clarity, but sometimes they're spaced in such a way that typing is not as smooth/easy from the get-go as a more standard keyboard. That was the case with the Alloy FPS: solid for gaming, a bit meh for typing. I did get used to it after some due diligence, but it was a standout drawback here that I didn't experience with the other keyboards I tested.

Logitech G413 Carbon

Logitech's G413 is the most affordable keyboard we tested, but don't let its price dissuade you. The G413 still wields Romer-G keys, a sturdy design, and gives ample real estate that's good for both gaming and typing. My one little pet peeve with the G413—which is available in either silver or carbon finishes—is the spring sound.

While all mechanical keyboards use springs to provide quick, clicky travel, the G413's spring-return noise (a high-pitched metallic ring) is more audible than any other keyboard here, to the point that I found it a bit distracting. While this isn't likely to be a problem if you're playing with headphones, or a game that's particularly loud/busy, in the opening moments of resource gathering in StarCraft I found the ringing mechanical sound to be irritating. This could be a fault of the Romer-G keys, or simply the G413's design.

However, outside of that tiny nitpick, this is a good choice for the asking price. It shaves off extraneous features and a bit of build quality to undercut the competition, but if you want entry-level, we recommend it.

Meet the tester

Lee Neikirk

Lee Neikirk

Editor

@Koanshark

Lee has been Reviewed's point person for most television and home theater products since 2012. Lee received Level II certification in TV calibration from the Imaging Science Foundation in 2013. As Editor of the Home Theater vertical, Lee oversees reviews of TVs, monitors, soundbars, and Bluetooth speakers. He also reviews headphones, and has a background in music performance.

See all of Lee Neikirk's reviews

Checking our work.

We use standardized and scientific testing methods to scrutinize every product and provide you with objectively accurate results. If you’ve found different results in your own research, email us and we’ll compare notes. If it looks substantial, we’ll gladly re-test a product to try and reproduce these results. After all, peer reviews are a critical part of any scientific process.

Shoot us an email