When it comes to essential knives, the paring knife is my number two pick. While the chef’s knife might be a total kitchen workhorse, that paring knife is more maneuverable. It effortlessly handles precision-oriented tasks that often take place off the cutting board, like peeling apples and deveining shrimp. Given a choice of any knife, I’ll reach for a sharp paring knife–like our top pick Wüsthof Classic 3.5-inch High Carbon Steel Paring Knife(available at Amazon)–anytime I’m looking to make a cut that requires a high level of control.
Some cooks say that, since you don’t use it as often, you should buy a cheap paring knife and replace it when it gets dull. That’s certainly an option–and we’ve provided a few value picks that will fit that bill. But, after testing 10 top-performing 3- to 4-inch paring knives, we found that they’re like most things: with one notable exception, you generally get what you pay for.
Here are the best paring we tested knives ranked, in order:
Wüsthof Classic 3.5-inch High Carbon Steel Paring Knife
The Wusthof Classic 3.5-inch High Carbon Steel Paring Knife is on the high end of knives we tested (coming in just under $50), but it’s completely worth it. It immediately pulled away from the pack with its perfectly balanced handle and streamlined design. In addition to great maneuverability and a high level of control, it comfortably hung out in my palm as I peeled and deveined shrimp. When the sharp blade made quick work of every task we threw at it (including a perfect apple peel and beautiful orange segments), we knew it was a shoo-in for our top pick as Best Overall.
There’s nothing to hate about the price tag on the Victorinox 3.25-inch Paring Knife–especially considering how well it performed on our tests. Its ultra-lightweight design made it easy to use off the cutting board and it only slightly lagged behind our top pick. After making quick work of coring strawberries without tiring our hands and peeling apples without so much as a snag, we knew this sharp blade rivaled most of its more expensive competitors. We know we said you get what you pay for, but this knife seems to be the exception to the rule. Because of that, it solidly landed our pick for Best Value.
Hi, I’m Lindsay Mattison, a trained professional chef. I tend to use a chef's knife for most of my cutting tasks, but I couldn't live without my trusty paring knife. It’s small, it’s sharp, and it’s perfect for any task that requires a lot of precision–like carving tomato roses! Okay, maybe those should stay on the ‘90’s buffet line, but in all seriousness, the paring knife is an essential part of my knife kit. I've had a personal favorite for years (you'll read about it in a minute!) and I want to help you find yours.
We chose 10 paring knives between 3- to 4-inches in length–an adequate size to perform all the classic paring knife tasks while still being short enough to control. We were looking for a knife that could handle off-the-cutting-board tasks like peeling fruits while still being comfortable to use for precision tasks (like mincing shallots). Our tests were designed to evaluate sharpness, comfort, and control.
Any good knife should be sharp out of the box, but the paring knife needs a nice edge to handle slicing food in the air. We peeled apples and segmented oranges to see how well each knife could handle the in-air tasks before mincing shallots to see how sharp it was on the board.
It's also important that a paring knife feels comfortable in our hands as we work suspended in the air. In addition to assessing how easily it peeled apples in a circular motion, we wanted to know how it felt sitting standby in our hands. In a restaurant setting, you don't always have time to set down your knife in between tasks. So, while we were peeling the shrimp with our fingertips, we checked to see if the knife sat comfortably in the palm of our hand while still being ready to spring into action when it was time to devein.
Finally, the knife had to have a nice balance between the blade and handle lengths, giving us the maximum amount of control as we used it. We assessed the shape, both on and off the cutting board, and determined if it could easily get into tight places. After coring strawberries - choking up on the sharp blade - we knew if each knife could cut with precision while still being safe to use.
What You Should Know About Paring Knives
A paring knife is a small but mighty knife that usually measures between 2.5 to 4-inches long. Cooks often use these when a regular chef’s knife is too large and they are perfect for precision-based cutting tasks. Paring knives are easy to manage and especially convenient for slicing, coring, and peeling.
What Is A Paring Knife Used For?
A paring knife is very versatile and can be used for preparing meats, fruits, or vegetables. Some popular uses for paring knives include deveining shrimp, peeling ingredients, coring tomatoes, decasing sausage, hulling strawberries, and scoring meat.
What To Look For When Buying A Paring Knife
Paring knives are a worthwhile investment if you’re an avid cook and handle a lot of delicate tasks. If you decide to invest in a full knife set, make sure it includes a paring knife. The most important features to look for in a paring knife include:
Comfortable grip: Take care to choose a paring knife that is comfortable to grip, as you’ll be holding it tightly.
Blade-to-handle ratio: Balance is essential when shopping for a paring knife. Make sure that the size and weight of the blade are equal, or it’ll be awkward to use.
Blade size: You have a variety of sizes to choose from when shopping for a paring knife, but we’ve found the best option is 3.25 to 3.5 inches.
Other Paring Knives We Tested
Global GS-38 Classic 3.5-Inch Paring Knife
If you take a peek inside my personal knife bag, you’ll find a Global 3.5-inch Western Style Paring Knife. While it didn’t outperform our top picks, it’s still a sturdy knife with an ultra-sharp edge (thanks to the Japanese steel). The hollow handle perfectly balanced the not-too-short but not-too-long blade, keeping us in control as we used it. In addition to top marks on all of the tests, this one is also a bit of a showpiece – that iconic textured handle would make a stunning addition to your knife block.
Anyone who has gone to culinary school knows the Mercer name–this brand makes the standard knife kit for first year students. For the price, there’s a lot to like about the Mercer Culinary Genesis 3.5-inch Forged Paring Knife–the blade was impressively sharp for such an inexpensive knife and it did well on most of our tests. Our major complaint is its weight. Compared to the competition, the bulky handle felt heavy in our hands and the shape made peeling and deveining shrimp an awkward experience.
ZWILLING J.A. Henckels Four-Star 4-Inch Paring Knife
I gotta say, I love the handle material on the ZWILLING J.A. Henckels Four-Star 4-inch Paring Knife. It’s soft and smooth without any noticeable edges or sharp corners. When you’re holding a paring knife for an extended period of time, you really appreciate small details like that! Unfortunately, the 4-inch blade was just a bit too long and it struggled on precision tasks like segmenting oranges.
J.A. Henckels International Classic 4-Inch Paring/Utility Knife
Once again, between the 4-inch blade and the long handle on the J.A. Henckels International Classic 4-inch Paring Knife, this knife felt just a touch too long. It had a hard time getting into tight spaces to core strawberries and it wasn't maneuverable enough to segment citrus. In addition, the handle itself had sharp angles that made it uncomfortable to hold for long periods of time.
The Kuhn Rikon 4-inch Nonstick Paring Knife Colori has a plastic handle and a nonstick carbon steel blade. It comes with a plastic sheath, which makes it easy to take on-the-go. But, when it came down to performance, I wouldn’t recommend this model as your go-to knife. The slick plastic handle was slippery and the blade’s large, jutting butt end threatened to slice our fingers if we choked up on the blade.
I was surprised that the Opinel No 112 4-inch Paring Knife was so maneuverable given its 4-inch length, but it still wasn’t my favorite knife of the group. While it was nice and lightweight, it just wasn’t as sharp as some of the competition and the straight-bladed design made it difficult to hold while deveining shrimp. It definitely rings in at a value price, but there are better options in this price range.
We use standardized and scientific testing methods to scrutinize every product and provide you with objectively accurate results. If you’ve found different results in your own research, email us and we’ll compare notes. If it looks substantial, we’ll gladly re-test a product to try and reproduce these results. After all, peer reviews are a critical part of any scientific process.